Quote Originally Posted by Valkyrie_Lenneth View Post
Because the defense is based around defending the up. If you say "we don't like this site, and it infringes on our up, but that site is good, even though it infringes on our ip, the judge would throw it out.
A judge would not make a decision based on how good the site is. The decision is made based on whether it does infringe copyright or damages the IP.