Quote Originally Posted by Izsha View Post
Actually yes you are.

Enmity is just a binary effect. Pass fail. Monster targets the person with the highest enmity. The end. If that is you, even by a single point then the boss will choose you.

If a dps has 100 enmity, a healer has 130 enmity, and you the tank have 150 enmity, you win. You dont win 'harder' by having 500 enmity or 1000 enmity. The monster will attack you under any condition where your enmity is above the rest of the party.

Once you have a nice cushion of enmity you should deal damage as more enmity has zero effect. The monster is already hitting you. You won the enmity game. Now you need to win the actual fight by killing it.
Okay.

Sure.

But if your threat lead is literally 1, you're losing aggro the next moment.

If your threat lead is 50k, you're losing it in 10.

I've only got so many cooldowns to bust through to lower or prevent that. If your threat lead is literally just the "A" with no bar length to back it up, you're throttling people.