Commending DPS

[DumdogsWorld]

I commend people (not just DPS, but any role) based on a list of exclusion rather than a ranking of who's best.

If people annoy me because:

-They're mean.
-They're not doing their job/role correctly.
-They're in a situation where they should know the mechanics, but fall into their traps anyway. I always cut first-timers some slack.
-They're technically doing what they're supposed to, but in a very inefficient manner. For example, plucking off enemies one by one from a huge mob as a single-target DPS while having full MP/TP and having obvious access to AOE abilities.

...then I cross their name off the list of candidates. Then, when the dungeon is over, I take whoever is left and do eeny meeny miny moe.

There are occasional exceptions, but they're not common. Stuff like healer lb3 without being asked, etc.