1. If I notice a bard aoeing and hooking me and tanky up with Refresh and Tactician respectfully.
2. If the Tank was just awful in aggro management, usually I'll give it to a DPS that stayed out of bad circles.
3. If the DPS is the only one's left around
4. If I like their name.
5. If I like their glam.
6. If I like their glam.
7. If it's obvious that they're new but they still tried, I'll commend them.
8. Eeny meeny miny moe (A fast version of this mind you). Not even kidding.