Here's the comparisons for healing drops as well.

Eye Drops (cures Blindness)
(The only recipe that actually all around costs less)
  • 150% less shards
  • No Rock Salt (400% less)
  • 33% less Blindfish
Throat Drops (cures Silence)
  • 25% less shards
  • Same amount of Rock Salt
  • 200% more Tarantula
Dawn Drops (cures Sleep)
  • 283% less shards
  • 33% less Rock Salt
  • 50% more Belladonna
Spine Drops (cures Paralysis)
(Oops, I lied, this recipe actually costs 1 more shard overall per dozen produced)
  • 4% more shards
  • 50% more Rock Salt
  • 350% more Black Scorpion
Nerve Drops (cures Madness)
  • 192% less shards
  • Same amount of Rock Salt
  • 200% more Mandrake
Blood Drops (cures Poison)
  • 1067% less shards (3 instead 35 to make a dozen)
  • 33% less Rock Salt
  • 125% more Grass Viper
Lung Drops (cures Smothered?)
  • 63% less shards
  • 50% more Rock Salt
  • 500% more Blowfish
Heart Drops (cures Disabled)
  • 63% less shards
  • 50% more Rock Salt
  • 500% more Dart Frog