Quote Originally Posted by Eli85 View Post
Too many insulting and trolling replies to quote, but the fact that the responses are all, "You don't know what you're talking about," instead of actually discussing and giving reasons why I'm wrong is telling. Look, outside of giving the big personal DPS jobs every buff in the book, DPS enmity just does not outpace tank enmity when the tank is being played correctly. I have seen this play out in groups way too many times to doubt it. If you look at BLM in particular, and you start in Umbral Ice (which you will for every single raid encounter), the most popular guide even says, point blank, that you do not need to use Diversion. So are the BLM theorycrafters also ignorant? Please.

Ultimately I—and hopefully many others—will take empirical experience and theorycrafters over the opinions of insult and troll-ready posters.

This is true however it is a group dps loss because the tank would need to use enmity generation combos.

However nobody really cares for min/max in a dungeon.

But when the tank has minimum ilvl and dps has maximum ilvl if the dps is not using enmity reducing cooldowns then no matter how hard the tank spams his/her aggro combo, the dps will then become the tank.