Personally I'm okay with Black and White magic having similar rotations -- after all, the entire point of Red Mage is in learning how to keep them in balance, and if our rotation leans more towards one than the other for any given period then we'll not only defeat the philosophy of the class but relegate one to functional disuse.

As I keep saying: Neither of the current Ver-finishers should be an AoE. We should not have any AoE spells come off of the Enchanted Riposte combo, because that would compete with Moulinet, leading to one or the other being devalued (most likely the finisher). Dual-target scenarios where both enemies are within 5 feet of each other are too rare to justify dedicating one of our finishers to it, especially if it would lead to it getting nerfed in single-target and relegated to uselessness in general.
Any AoEs we gain from here on should either trigger from Moulinet or supplement Scatter -- and if I'm being perfectly honest, even a Ver-finisher off of 3 Moulinets is a tough sell, because it would take anywhere from 18 (on average) to 30 casts of Scatter to get enough Mana to triple-cast Moulinet, assuming they don't seriously change it with the TP removal in Shadowbringers anyway. I honestly think we may be better off just getting a direct means to accelerate the AoE melee combo, and maybe a buff to Moulinet.

Now that being said, I wouldn't be against us gaining one or two Black Magic-based situational utility skills, given that every Black Magic spell in our arsenal has a White Magic counterpart, but we have no Black Magic counterparts to Vercure or Verraise.
Of course the issue there, then, is that Black Mages don't have any utility anyway -- about the most situational spells they have are defenses and CC that could just as easily fall under White Magic anyway, rendering the philosophical aspect moot.