I don't think they need to be removed, but I do think they need to be reworked. At the least, the damage penalty is too high.




I don't think they need to be removed, but I do think they need to be reworked. At the least, the damage penalty is too high.
There shouldn't be a damage penalty for being in tank stance in the first place, not being in your dps stance is already a damage penalty.
You're essentially killing yourself every time you enter tank stance.


Having tanked a little bit I can see the validity of both sides. Back in HW I didn't really understand how to use Cleric stance properly and when they removed it I was really happy. And in all honesty it was a great learning tool for me. It helped me learn how to both heal and dps to great effect. That being said. Now that I know how to properly dps and heal I do miss the old Cleric Stance. It made the overworld easier and it made dpsing in dungeons more effective.
I think instead of going for one or the other we should have some kind of medium. I think adjusting stances in general would be better than out right removing them.
Removing CS didn't affect healer DPS much at all. Healer damage spells now work on MND, not INT. The overall DPS is about the same, just no need to stance dance.


huh. I could very well be wrong. I never looked at the math and such. All I know is that the general potency of healer dps was nerfed when stance was changed however if the increased up time balances this out then good deal.
No, and I really do mean no.
If everyone else is doing what they should to reduce their own hate creation and the tank is still loosing hate, then that is on the tanks and they need to learn how to tank.
If the healers are healing as they should and the tank is still dying, then either their gear is really bad or they need to learn how to use their mitigation skills.
Generating hate in this game is already way to easy, the skills we have to mitigate damage are really powerful and we have more then enough of them.
Tanks in this game are already dps with a bigger hp pool and heavy armor, do we really need to dumb it down even more?



They should remove it and add enmity stat to tanks gear. Also add enmity and defense combined materia for tanks.




I'm a tank that primarily uses their DPS stance. I've yet to die specifically because of this in years.
I've yet to have aggro management issues in months.
Tanking isn't hard.
But some people make it hard on themselves.
Not everyone is bad at tanking, some are simply learning. Some...are bad.
Don't try to change an entire role mechanic because of a couple poor situations.
http://king.canadane.com



I’d rather they add actual hair physics.


Tank stances definitely need a rework. It's long been the case that tanks have skirted the edge of survivability; as long as they can stay alive, any resources beyond that should go to DPS. This made tank stance more of an enmity tool than a survivability tool - but the addition of Shirk pretty much made that a non-issue, as well. Now, in the toughest content, tanks are rarely in tank stance outside of the first rotation or so; sometimes not even that. Tank stance is ironically used more in casual dungeons, and such, to enable ridiculously large mob group pulls (which they enable with aplomb).
Not sure what could be done to make tank stances more relevant, but they're on the edge of irrelevancy as it stands.
|
|
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
|
|
Cookie Policy
This website uses cookies. If you do not wish us to set cookies on your device, please do not use the website. Please read the Square Enix cookies policy for more information. Your use of the website is also subject to the terms in the Square Enix website terms of use and privacy policy and by using the website you are accepting those terms. The Square Enix terms of use, privacy policy and cookies policy can also be found through links at the bottom of the page.
Reply With Quote





