Can we remove Tank Stance?

[shao32]

Citation needed. I have seen Yoshi say tanks do too much damage, but I have yet to see him saying he’s “dissapointed” in players tanking out of defensive stances. He didn’t even care about nearly everybody abusing WAR strat in o5s.
Even disregarding that, just because something wasn’t intended, doesn’t mean it’s bad and should go away. Housing glitches were certainly not intentional design, but they’re the main thing that keeps the system interesting.

im trying to find it, but to be more precise yoshi answer was around WARs don't using defiance

That is the point. Having this gap is what having room for improvement means.

you don't get it, the tank stance gap make bad/turtle tanks being worse that they currently are just bcs the damage penalty, there is not real skill by having it off or turning it on since what the tank stance offers you isn't need it outside the pull and don't really change you gameplay having it on/off.

Then explain why tanks cannot beat Stone Sky Sea for EX or Savage in tank stance at ilv. I mean they won't even come close, you literally can't do it.

SSS was created by the devs, tailored individually to each class, intended to show whether or not you have the recommended dps for your class. EX and Savage bosses, which have tight enrage timers, are designed with the assumption that both tanks spend the maximum time possible in dps stance.

The current use of stances is not only intentional, it's mandatory to beat the hardest content.

melichoir say everything what i want to say, even with the MT always on tank stance fight mechanics force you to swap with you co-tank so you obviously turn you tank stance off and hit harder, you don't really estay 100% of the encounter in tank stance and SSS reflect that, since they calculated the dps you are supose to push on those moments.