Alright, I Did It. [Blue mage Review]

[Sylvain]

I'm glad BLU has the majority or the low % learn in instanced content. Trying to learn with overworld mob was hell. Since the majority of the game is instanced content, what's the problem with finding a group if the entire game is basicaly that?

The problem is that some spell just have ridiculously low %chance to be learned and most content can't be solo'd. Which IS a big problem for a job that is meant to be solo.
I should be able to solo (or easily duo at least) all the lv 50 dungeons with a BLU friend quick enough to make the farming fun.

This is currently not the case, we are simply too weak to do so and having 1 70 carry 3 BLU is the most effective way to learn spells. (which is dull for everyone)

Primordial also don't help, 5% chance is very very low.
Like, "on average" it will take 20 runs, that's a lot, and I feel sorry for those who'll run 50+ primordial

The main post review is, in my opinion, very good and actually quite neutral.
There was no "I wanted it to be X ways", it was a critic on what was advertised, a solo job with combo skills

It is a solo job (masked carnival) but the mean to acquire too many spells (half the book, required to complete the solo content) isn't solo. Grouping should be an option, and being carried by a lv 70 shouldn't be the best way to complete the book (nor to level)
There are spell combo, but most are weaker than spamming a stronger version. This could easily be adressed by simply buffing potency, but at the current moment, it's combo are weak thus uninteresting. (Boosting the combo potency could help BLU solo content)

Having a few spell locked behind group is fine, like the primordial spells. Heck, they could even promote BLU grouping by increasing the chance of acquiring a spell the more BLU there is in a party.
Like a stackable 5% per BLU in a party. See, this would be fine, because it wouldn't be half the book, and doing with other BLU would be better than doing it with 70's

The marking is also honest imo. 6/10
It could be better, definitely, but it's not also a total failure, I'm still having fun, I believe most people had some fun until they started seeing the glaring issue with what was posted.

It is important to give good (and neutral) feedback so the devs can adjust.

If everyone complain "you say it's solo but I have to party/be carried for half the book, that's not solo!" then they can adjust for the next tier (or simply update and boost BLU's spell potency)
If everyone complain that there are too many similar spells and combo aren't strong enough, they know it's something that needs to be adressed.