Why another complex minigame that will probably die in 2 weeks?

[Alleo]

I'm trying to figure out the point you are trying to make. First is seems you are saying that an orchestration scroll, of all things, is too valuable a reward for a mini-game. Then it seems you are saying that enjoyment should be a game content's own reward, to which I'm left wondering what the point of any reward is in that situation.

What kind of content do you feel justifies getting an orchestration scroll from?

Instances where the music plays. And if the music plays in gold saucer then let it be bought with MGP. IMO Mini games themselves dont need rewards. Playing them should be rewarding enough. And if you need to have some kind of reward to make the Gold saucer more interesting in the long run then do it like the mounts and stuff and put it behind MGP. This way people can get the rewards by playing the mini games that they like. Other content like dungeons do need more rewards because they need to be kept at least a bit alive because newer people need to run it too while mini games are just a nice spare time investment.

I mean you can always run old stuff again for drops. LoV and their minions are for example locked away for players if they did not get it when it was still active enough, the same might happen with Mahjong. So if you still want those minions you might need to "cheat" for it by getting friends togethter who are winning or losing on purpose. I just dont find that good.