I am all for a Coliseum in the Gladiators Guild. It's already there. May as well use it. Nothing like a little friendly competition to get the blood pumping in the morning. Like OP said, if you can't run away that's more fair. Make the PvP instanced in the Glad Guild. Even if people could sign up as spectators, that'd be fun. There's lots of people standing around in Ul'dah that'd like some entertainment anyways. Hey they could even let you wager Gil on who you think will win. Your Buddies, or the other guys...