Primals of shadows and stars

[Hegarl]

Hi
I want to hear your thoughts.
I like Attribute.
So, I gathered all the primarl weapons of ARR.
However, there are no primals for shadows and star attributes, so they are being replaced by different Weapons.
Do you think shadows and star attributes will be created later?
I really want them to be made.
Have a nice day!

[Urthdigger]

No primals for shadows and stars, so they're being replaced by different weapons? I have no idea what you're asking about.

[Hegarl]

I'm sorry.
I'm not good at English.
All I want is a lot like Dead Hive Claws.
A weapon on the theme of Umbral and Astral.
And I was wondering what people thought about it.
Thank you for your answer!

[Iscah]

I'm guessing you're playing in another language, and mean what are called "umbral" and "astral" in the English version? The two non-elemental aspects that items can have? (Or in phrases such as "Astral Eras" and "Umbral Eras".)

[Hegarl]

Oh, I'm sorry.
I came to the US for studying.
I'm learning English and I'm not good at it yet.
Not only is the name too confusing: '(
umbral and astral are right.
Thanks for the reply!

[KageTokage]

Astral/umbral are more like polarities because each of the elements can be attuned to either.

[Iscah]

Astral/umbral are more like polarities because each of the elements can be attuned to either.

Good point, though items are still sometimes described as being aspected to astral/umbral.

[alimdia]

Thordan crafted weapons aren't exactly that, but they have a light visual effect that is the closest thing you're gonna get for an astral weapon. Crafted Nidhogg weapons are the closest thing to an umbral weapon.

[Hegarl]

Thordan crafted weapons aren't exactly that, but they have a light visual effect that is the closest thing you're gonna get for an astral weapon. Crafted Nidhogg weapons are the closest thing to an umbral weapon.

Thank you.
I already use both weapons as a substitute.
However, I hope there will be clear Umbral and Astral weapons.
So I wanted to hear the opinion that the gods and weapons that symbolize the two Elementals can be created.
The answer is only knows the PD, but I hope they are made.

[Tsumdere]

We have not had astral and umbral weapons because they are based off of the primal's theme, and we have not really had an astral or umbral primal.

The closest we have gotten is Tsukuyomi with purple/moon theme, but her crafted will not added for at the very least another year or two.