Results 1 to 10 of 41

Thread: Holy knight

Hybrid View

  1. #1
    Player
    Kabooa's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2013
    Posts
    4,393
    Character
    Jace Ossura
    World
    Gilgamesh
    Main Class
    Goldsmith Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by JunseiKei View Post
    tl;dr
    Job identity (PvP and PvE) and animations to lend itself to enough realism to not make it utterly ridiculous, and not in the same way someone can wear a metallic green pig-suit kind of ridiculous.
    There's almost no realism beyond the basic low level weaponskills among animations. You really can't use that argument. Just in the Paladin's weapon models alone there's enough variance that the animations hardly line up with what the sword should be used as.

    The Dark Knight Animations work with literally any metal stick, let alone differentiating them between the various models of actual swords.

    This goes on and on between the various weapon types.
    (2)

  2. #2
    Player
    JunseiKei's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2013
    Location
    The Mist, Ward 9, Plot 2
    Posts
    1,800
    Character
    Xoria Tepes
    World
    Cactuar
    Main Class
    White Mage Lv 90
    Quote Originally Posted by GrumbleBeard View Post
    I agree, which is why it would be fine to have it despite similarities in the theme.
    Was saying that in the confines that for all we know, PLD is FFXIV's iteration of Holy Knight. Or it might not. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ I actually don't know, especially when you consider Yoshida saying the Warriors of Darkness are classes/jobs that we don't have (IE: their "PLD" might be a Holy Knight because he was saying it was another universe).

    Quote Originally Posted by Kabooa View Post
    There's almost no realism beyond the basic low level weaponskills among animations. You really can't use that argument. Just in the Paladin's weapon models alone there's enough variance that the animations hardly line up with what the sword should be used as.

    The Dark Knight Animations work with literally any metal stick, let alone differentiating them between the various models of actual swords.

    This goes on and on between the various weapon types.
    I can and will use that argument as it is part of the whole that is world building. Yes, Dark Knight animations "work" with any object you place in their hands. That doesn't mean it won't look terrible, break lore or just make no sense. You're essentially telling me a MNK will look just as fine using a spear with their animations as their fists; that is the difference of placing a shortsword in the hands of a Dark Knight, whose animations are built around a claymore.

    All of which feeds back into the game staying true to its core/lore; if a class/job only uses a certain weapon, then that class/job only uses that weapon. In PLD's case, the lore states they are the "shield of the sultanate" boasting "stalwart shieldwork and exquisite swordplay." - Encyclopaedia Eorzea, page 218. Seems they are pretty intent on keeping the class/job consistent.




    However, and I'm not changing my stance in this debate, as I really don't see the FFXIV team changing the weapons of existing classes/jobs, I don't think the weapons of current classes means they won't be seen/used again on another class. As it is, SCH and SMN both use a book (grimoire and codex) as well as WHM and BLM both use rods (cane and staff).
    (1)
    Last edited by JunseiKei; 11-02-2018 at 06:17 PM. Reason: Edit for multi-quoting.
    9.23.2019 [11:15 p.m.]Total Play Time: 1552 days, 0 hours, 0 minutes - You'll be hard-pressed to find a more cynical person than me.
    Quote Originally Posted by Odstarva View Post
    You people are never happy.
    [...] You complain and complain and complain.

  3. #3
    Player
    Kabooa's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2013
    Posts
    4,393
    Character
    Jace Ossura
    World
    Gilgamesh
    Main Class
    Goldsmith Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by JunseiKei View Post
    I can and will use that argument as it is part of the whole that is world building. Yes, Dark Knight animations "work" with any object you place in their hands. That doesn't mean it won't look terrible, break lore or just make no sense. You're essentially telling me a MNK will look just as fine using a spear with their animations as their fists; that is the difference of placing a shortsword in the hands of a Dark Knight, whose animations are built around a claymore.
    Except they're more appropriate with the PVP Glamour weapon, the beatstick. Seriously. The Beatstick makes it seem like the Dark Knight -should- have been a two handed club job, because the consideration of weight and momentum given to the animations fits a crushing weapon far better. When the sword is big enough, it's not really about it being a sword anymore.

    Put a giant metal stick in Guts's hand, and he'll use it exactly like his sword, it'll just leave a bigger mess behind.
    (0)

  4. #4
    Player
    JunseiKei's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2013
    Location
    The Mist, Ward 9, Plot 2
    Posts
    1,800
    Character
    Xoria Tepes
    World
    Cactuar
    Main Class
    White Mage Lv 90
    Quote Originally Posted by Kabooa View Post
    Except they're more appropriate with the PVP Glamour weapon, the beatstick. Seriously. The Beatstick makes it seem like the Dark Knight -should- have been a two handed club job, because the consideration of weight and momentum given to the animations fits a crushing weapon far better. When the sword is big enough, it's not really about it being a sword anymore.

    Put a giant metal stick in Guts's hand, and he'll use it exactly like his sword, it'll just leave a bigger mess behind.
    The PvP club? You mean the onii club, Kanabō? This is why I said at least part of this is grounded in reality - a two-handed club/blunt weapon doesn't exist in reality. At least, not in that way. The closest equivalent is a bo or rod. After that, you find maces or possibly the Macuahuitl, which is a PLD arm already (and single handed). It's also said that Dark Knight did take inspiration from Berserk.

    Speaking of Berserk (which is why I'm guessing you brought up Guts)...

    ...With Guts though, he doesn't like normal swords. He actively turns down smaller swords when offered (happened once or twice). He always uses a claymore. Also, you're not getting a much bigger sword than Dragonslayer.

    (In my opinion, none of the moves would fit with a club - you don't use a blunt weapon the same way as a slashing weapon, but you may use it similarly to a piercing one. That's probably why DRG got the Eastern Journey Battle Staff item.)
    (0)
    9.23.2019 [11:15 p.m.]Total Play Time: 1552 days, 0 hours, 0 minutes - You'll be hard-pressed to find a more cynical person than me.
    Quote Originally Posted by Odstarva View Post
    You people are never happy.
    [...] You complain and complain and complain.