Quote Originally Posted by Melichoir View Post
[...] I can spot bad tanks without a meter. One form of dead give away: tanking in tank stance for the entirety of the fight (Game in its current iteration is not designed for tanks to stay in tank stance the entire fight, but to use it as a cooldown or to grab initial enmity).
Not a good example. They aren't necessarily bad, just maybe perhaps they more comfortable in staying in that stance instead of dancing between them. And I rather give the healer more wiggle room to possibly DPS and save the healing for DPS roles that fail mechanics, than me (a PLD) do a spec more damage.

Speaking of which, even with stance dancing, the DPS still are a issue these days - With all 10 role actions at their disposal, they still don't use Diversion or other actions frequently. And not to mention using single target attacks on groups of 4 and more. And much more.

I rather like the parser to have a stab on the bottom line and get the real bads thrown out of the door rather than antagonize anyone else, as long the performance they do is sufficient.