Commendations are just so broken

[DrWho2010]

You're a RED MAGE, there is pretty good chance you're lower on dmg meter than the other guy, so prolly why you're not getting any coms. I get them tons on BLM unless I can reach the exit portal fast. I also always com the tank unless he sissy pulls, then healer. Only if both suck other dps so that's very rare.

did you just assume his damage potential just because he's a red mage? sissy pulls? you must be a real treat to party up with.

[FFgame]

did you just assume his damage potential just because he's a red mage? sissy pulls? you must be a real treat to party up with.

Assume? I run dmg meter while I play. I know what each class can pull given the gear. Red mage needs dmg buff.
I'm the one that runs for exit portal at the end so not to get spammed with comms. That's how fun I am to party with.

[Kurando]

snip

OP mentioned dungeons which is casual content. Why should it matter who is bringing out the most damage in this situation? A DPS could be doing the least damage but doesn't necessarily mean they are preventing the dungeon from being cleared, just like a healer could do nothing but only heal during the entire instance, so if they are bringing less to the duty in this sense does this mean they forfit any chance of commendations? Other things could prevent them playing optimally, but again who decides what would be optimal in casual content, generally no one but that player themselves.

Spammed with comms? Sure....