On the subject of tattoos I think there could be an alternative that would satisfy all if not most players. Currently the Mark of the Twelve uses a system that lets you toggle it on or off by typing /lmark into the chat window meaning technically all character models have it but the command just does nothing for characters made after ARR I suppose. By using this same system and adding an ability to choose different marks you could essentially let everyone apply a tattoo to a character's body while keeping the Mark of the Twelve exclusive to pre-ARR characters. Just make that mark unobtainable but different ones available and for sale via the Mog Station or as rewards in-game. To keep it simple only one mark/tattoo can be applied at one time meaning if a legacy character wants to display a different mark they can't use it and the Mark of the Twelve at the same time. The system is already there, just disable the command to toggle it and make the marks/tattoos applicable via the Aesthetican instead.