I fully support this thread. I strongly believe that there is a need for SE to officially designate a roleplay-friendly server.
FFXIV's roleplay community is made up of an established and loyal customer base. They enjoy an additional aspect of the game via player-created story. This sandbox element isn't dependent upon a steady stream of new content (which benefits the devs), and it breathes life into their surroundings (which benefits the local community). But this is dependent upon one crucial factor, and that is like-minded individuals being able to come together in one place.
Why do we need SE's help to do this?
For Roleplayers:
While current players may have the knowledge that Besaid has been established as the unofficial RP server, new players should not be expected to know this. Though that knowledge made front-page news during the hype of launch, it has since fallen quiet. Plus, if SE goes ahead with their original plan to force everyone to choose a new and anonymously numbered server this March, the new RP hub may not even be called Besaid. New players who actually take the time to research and read the old news may choose Besaid in error. This could be avoided if a server was designated in-game as RP-friendly during the server selection screen.
For The Roleplay-Friendly:
Believe it or not, there are many people who don't actively roleplay themselves, but still enjoy playing on roleplay servers. They choose RP servers due to the fact they generally tend to foster a more friendly, helpful and mature community. Plus, many say that roleplay is fun to witness, even if they do not actively participate, because it adds extra flavor and life to their game environment. Again, designating a server RP-friendly would help these people find the enjoyable experience and atmosphere they're looking for.
For The Non-Roleplayers:
There are those who do not wish to be exposed to roleplay in any way, shape or form.
If you've spent any reasonable amount of time playing on Besaid, you will know of at least one story like this one: One night I wandered into Ul'dah to hear someone going on in /shouts in a very annoyed tone, wanting to know what was up with all the roleplay on the server. This was met with the response that Besaid was the RP server, and that they should expect to run into it from time to time. This person was genuinely surprised and even angry to learn this. They said they would have NEVER created their character on Besaid had they known!
These are the people that will most likely not research server types, and will be most surprised to find themselves unknowingly on a RP server. If this information was made available at the server selection screen, those who do not enjoy roleplay would know which server to avoid.
If nothing else, I would repeat the quote from
last October's Eorzepedia interview where Yoshi-P recognized the need for a designated roleplay server:
French/German speaking players are being granted an officially recommended server so their community has the opportunity to congregate in one place. This is only asking for the same thing. And now is the perfect time to provide it.
I support an officially recognized roleplay-friendly server!