[dev1237] Why take skill out of crafting?

[AuctionGirl]

If we wait until we see it, our opinions may not ever be heard. This isn't going to stop the 10000's of pointless spamming of crafting that many people want. The reason I make this thread is not to be bashed, but to have a discussion on this, and get more clarification from the Devs.

So lets have a discussion, not a bashing. If you don't agree, post why and the reasons you feel it should be that way. And if you do agree, feel free to comment also. We need more constructive criticism in this game, not bashing because you disagree.

[TheVedis]

If we wait until we see it, our opinions may not ever be heard. This isn't going to stop the 10000's of pointless spamming of crafting that many people want. The reason I make this thread is not to be bashed, but to have a discussion on this, and get more clarification from the Devs.

So lets have a discussion, not a bashing. If you don't agree, post why and the reasons you feel it should be that way. And if you do agree, feel free to comment also. We need more constructive criticism in this game, not bashing because you disagree.

um...we arent bashing you, we are pointing out you dont even understand what you are reading, as seems to be the case with a ton of people right now with this announcement

its pretty black and white but people will of course see what they want to see

[AuctionGirl]

Ok maybe I'm confused, by why split the 2 into 2 different categories...

Why not list it as...

If you finish with 600 quality, you will have 10% chance of HQ, 800 = 50% and 1000 = 100% chance.

That is what you are saying, but the way they posted this, doesn't make me think what you are saying.

[TheVedis]

Ok maybe I'm confused, by why split the 2 into 2 different categories...

Why not list it as...

If you finish with 600 quality, you will have 10% chance of HQ, 800 = 50% and 1000 = 100% chance.

That is what you are saying, but the way they posted this, doesn't make me think what you are saying.

they arent splitting it into 2 catagoriesm they are giving you examples of what an hq synth may finish at vs an nq synth!

since what this patch is doing is increasing quality on hq and chance to hq with hq mats

[AuctionGirl]

Then please clarify EXACTLY what this means to you...

(Example)
When all items are HQ items
Final Quality will be between 800–1,000 (odds of producing an HQ item range from 50% to 100%).

When all items are normal items
Final Quality will be between 300–600 (odds of producing an HQ item range from 0% to 10%).

[TheVedis]

Then please clarify EXACTLY what this means to you...

it means that when you use all nq mats, you will probably finish with 300-600 quality

when you use all hq mats, you will rpobably finish with 800-1000 thus increasing your hq chances


with clever use of abilities you can probly scew those numbers a ton(and with unstable synths blowing up you can easily get lower then that too i bet)


its not saying "hq mats give you this, nq give you this" its giving you the estimated range you will probably finish with IF you are trying to get higher quality



in the end it equates to 1 huge factor, using hq materials will actualy greatly increase your chance to hq an item!

[northernsky]

Then please clarify EXACTLY what this means to you...

All HQ mats = an offset of ~500 to starting quality

Keep in mind that you may have also have some, but not all HQ mats in your recipe, therefore, the offset may be 200 instead of 500

[Yoohre_WildRiver]

They are just removing random generated numers and making HQ items actually worth something, yo people are over complicating this and are not taking into consideration that the higher the quality the harder the synthesis becomes

[RemVye]

Reading Comprehension is the root cause for 90% of the Lodestone Forum threads/posts.

[AuctionGirl]

Maybe I need English as a Second Language to understand this. Or they need better interpreters. I have a feeling I am correct about how its going to work, and you guys are comprehending this incorrectly.

Can we please get a DEV to clarify how this will work. Thank you.