Custom Photoshop Help Needed!

[MystinaValeth]

Okay, so I have two shield designs that I've made so far. I've made two versions of the same shield (a simple design and a complex design), just wanted your opinion on which one you like better (or if you were imagining something a little different than these, I would like to hear what you'd like).

Once I get your opinion, I'll use one of these shields (or a different shield if you don't like these ones) in the banner I'll create for you.


Simple Shield



Complex Shield
(Extra shines and shield rim has extra bevel & emboss effects)