I agree with most of the things Trunks has listed. I really don't want to see another Stone give us something else I really want to see more water spells..
At the very least change Astro why is it a copy/paste.


I agree with most of the things Trunks has listed. I really don't want to see another Stone give us something else I really want to see more water spells..
At the very least change Astro why is it a copy/paste.
Last edited by Jxnibbles; 06-03-2018 at 04:51 PM.


You are so incredibly wrong that there is absolutely no reason to even begin to take you seriously.
But I'll humour you.
Fights are scripted.
oGCD usage is generally planned out around this scripted encounter.
Reducing the cooldown of your oGCDs by a few seconds does not allow you to use them any more freely than you would otherwise.
The design of lily usage means that you cannot use them strategically because any affected oGCD (usually Benison, which is nearly always used on cooldown) consumes them.
Lilies are a trap for players who don't know how to actually play the class effectively.
Also, Gauge mechanics don't deliver bigger boons for playing around them? Can be effectively ignored? You *really* think this?
*Oh dear* indeed.
Last edited by IttyBitty; 06-03-2018 at 04:37 PM.


Both of you missed the point that the Lily gauge is not a Limit break bar. Turn the gauge off, you will not miss it.

That is precisely the problem.
WHM is designed in such a way that encourages you to cast Cure and Cure II as infrequently as possible, because your rDPS contribution comes entirely from your pDPS, which shares a GCD with Cure/II. That is the essence of WHM gameplay: balancing your GCD usage to maximize your combined healing and damage output. Having a unique Job mechanic for which the game has dedicated tutorial pop-ups and which gets its own UI element be so trivial is incredibly counter-intuitive. Indeed, the way that Job gauges are so heavily emphasized actually steers people towards playing WHM incorrectly. That little Lily gauge indicates to people, "I should be trying to fill that up", when it's actually the opposite.
It feels like a lazy, tacked-on addition that they just tossed at the Job without much thought. Many Jobs didn't implement the Job gauges as well as they should have, but WHM's is the most egregious in giving the sense that it was an afterthought rather than an improvement.
Last edited by Trunks; 06-03-2018 at 05:03 PM.


So~ When are you going to post a video of Swallow's Compass / Hell's Lid / Fractual Continuum (Hard) so you can show us how you play WHM properly?I'd love to review that thoroughly like I did in the past with a previous video.
In all seriousness, the Lily system needs rework because the habits it teaches you effectively tells you to ignore optimizing 95% of the rest of your kit. If we're supposed to only use Tetra / Assize / Asylum when we have three lilies, we'll probably only end up using them one time each during the course of a raid encounter.
The CD reduction on lillies mean nothing if you aren't firing the CDs on cooldown but we have trouble generating Lillies because we can only get them from using single target heal spells. How counter intuitive is that?


I'm not a WHM player, so correct me if I'm wrong, but even in the context of all the conversations here...
Shouldn't you use the lilies the moment you hit 3? There's no bonus that I recall to having lilies (correct me if I am wrong) so holding onto them is literally wasting their potential unless you somehow have nothing to use it on.
For some reason, I was under the impression that each lily also increased potency of heals and shortened cast times on GCD skills. I don't know where I got this impression though, and switching to WHM myself to look at the tooltips, it seems that was never the case. Which means holding onto all 3 of them is even worse. Huh.I'm not a WHM player, so correct me if I'm wrong, but even in the context of all the conversations here...
Shouldn't you use the lilies the moment you hit 3? There's no bonus that I recall to having lilies (correct me if I am wrong) so holding onto them is literally wasting their potential unless you somehow have nothing to use it on.
Last edited by SaitoHikari; 06-04-2018 at 11:31 AM.
"Consider this old adage: When a Bard sings alone in a desert, and no one is around to hear him... Is he truly singing?"


Yeah, so I wasn't going crazy. I imagine if they *did* affect the skills like that they'd both be more useful and have a more meaningful choice while using them.For some reason, I was under the impression that each lily also increased potency of heals and shortened cast times on GCD skills. I don't know where I got this impression though, and switching to WHM myself to look at the tooltips, it seems that was never the case. Which means holding onto all 3 of them is even worse. Huh.
Actually, in all honesty, if the lilies actually did something beyond affect the cooldown of skills when they were used, would people have a better opinion of them? I don't know what WHM would find the most useful, though.
Last edited by Ilenya; 06-04-2018 at 11:44 AM.

I see you have fully grasped the scale of fallacy with which we're contending. Even from the point of view that was being argued, that statement is absurdly wrong. I thought maybe it was just a troll post, and the hits kept coming. Command mission healers are the best players. Yoshi-P is infallible, even at factual reality's expense. Using a parser makes you a bad player and a bad person. All the tamest replies are ignored while blanket-insulting everybody who disagrees (which seems to be everyone who's posted), then shrieking like a wounded deer when people respond in kind. Classic, toxic threadjacking, either intentionally trolling or too warped by a persecution complex to concede any point. The fact that they wouldn't even back down from the singularly ridiculous thing you've quoted makes it clear that there's no point taking a word of this seriously.
It depends what that "something" is, I suppose. If they had an effect to increase your damage output in some way then that would help to offset the loss of damage you sustain by using Cure and Cure II. Ultimately I think the range of possibilities is severely limited by the way Lilies are generated presently. It just does not make much sense with the way the Job functions in a live game setting.
Last edited by Trunks; 06-04-2018 at 12:06 PM.
Marry me?I see you have fully grasped the scale of fallacy with which we're contending. Even from the point of view that was being argued, that statement is absurdly wrong. I thought maybe it was just a troll post, and the hits kept coming. Command mission healers are the best players. Yoshi-P is infallible, even at factual reality's expense. Using a parser makes you a bad player and a bad person. All the tamest replies are ignored while blanket-insulting everybody who disagrees (which seems to be everyone who's posted), then shrieking like a wounded deer when people respond in kind. Classic, toxic threadjacking, either intentionally trolling or too warped by a persecution complex to concede any point. The fact that they wouldn't even back down from the singularly ridiculous thing you've quoted makes it clear that there's no point taking a word of this seriously.
/10char
|
|
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
|
|
Cookie Policy
This website uses cookies. If you do not wish us to set cookies on your device, please do not use the website. Please read the Square Enix cookies policy for more information. Your use of the website is also subject to the terms in the Square Enix website terms of use and privacy policy and by using the website you are accepting those terms. The Square Enix terms of use, privacy policy and cookies policy can also be found through links at the bottom of the page.
Reply With Quote
I'd love to review that thoroughly like I did in the past with a previous video.


