The purpose of this thread is to set a general idea of what were or are the key aspects of certain games that really made them shine. Yoshi-P does a great job with listening to the player base and does an amazing job with execution when it comes to popular desire.

It's easy to talk about the stuff you didn't or don't like. If you're feeling up to a bit of a challenge, how about talking about the stuff you DID or DO like in other games?

I'd like to set a rule for this thread - you MAY NOT argue, disagree, or mock anyone else's post. Period. It's pointless and stupid to argue about likes/dislikes, anyway. My favorite color is cobalt blue. Yours might be red. That doesn't make either of us better than the other one, you know?

You may, of course, agree with someone who expressed your personal like in an eloquent way, or be inspired by someone's post and riff on it. I just don't want to see any "you like BLUE? What kind of idiot likes BLUE?" posts in this thread.