Petition - Bring back the Need button in 24 mans

[Penthea]

Could, but this makes it easier.

It's only easier if the rolls work in your favour. You could potentially see an item drop several times, be the only person in the group playing a class who can equip it but watch someone else get it instead.

The absence of a need button actually makes it more difficult to get loot because you are relying on rng for it to drop, rng for the hope that you won't be rolling against several people, and more rng to have a roll high enough to win.

It's easier if the class you're playing actually has impact on your priority for loot, given you end up being far more likely to get something you roll need on.

[Alleo]

The real reason this change exists is due to the JP culture of running their main for 24man content, which I think would benefit the west as well. Less deaths during the raid = better experience farming the loot piece you need.

Funny since even the JP players seems to be mostly against this change, and some are even saying that people should go into a content with the job they want to gear otherwise they have not earned it. So Yoshida using that as a reason seems to shot them in their own foot.

[Okamimaru]

Another point... you don't need to greed ridorana loots to gear up for ridorana... creation gears would work just fine... or new dungeon gears... or buy some off mb... ridorana is 335 to enter... so the "I need them for my alt to run this content" excuse falls apart like a load of chocobo dung....

[Remedi]

If they are going to release the weekly lock on savage on 4.38 like they did with 4.18. Then it's clear they don't expect raiding ppl to really care abou 24 man gear.

[Okamimaru]

Also with this new greed only rule if you did enter with i340 gears on your main and actually DO need the gear you have a much worse chance at actually getting those gears... essentially you're saying that your alts gear is more important than someone's mains gear...

[Rockette]

Everyone is saying this is squares way of making content last but for me it's going to do the opposite. Now that I know I'm rolling against potentially 8 other people, some of which probably don't even have that class levelled I'm far less likely to try farm for a specific peice / glamour.

I'm just gonna do the weekly, get my coin and be done with it.

[Penthea]

Everyone is saying this is squares way of making content last but for me it's going to do the opposite.

Same. Usually I do SB group content on my lala alt too but the greed only in alliance raids has completely turned me off running them when I don't have to. I'm going to do it once a week for my weekly coin on my main and that's it.

I'm not even abstaining from doing extra runs as a form of protest. I really just don't want to put myself through the grief of watching gear I need go to someone else who may not even play the class at all, or watching drama unfold when it happens to other people. If I don't have to go to an unpleasant environment, I won't.

[Rockette]

Maybe this maint is bringing the need button back? ?

[AngelyLowell]

From my point of view, greed only make me want to run the raid only once in a week.

Why I should bother going back there if the probability to getting the gear I want is so low?

No thanks, going only for the coin and that is it.

[Aomine1992]

My ALT is a main healer and it kind of sucks to loose gear to someone who probably only needs the gear for faster ques but has not intentions only actually healing or tanking :/