Petition - Bring back the Need button in 24 mans

[Melondra]

I agree the need needs to be brought back, you should only be able to lot on the item that fits your current class that you entered the instance with. Prevents people from rolling on items that they cant use. If you want the item then bring that class into the instance.

[Policopiu]

This change needs to be reverted ASAP it just gimps new players why call it a catch up patch if its way harder to catchup now

[Ash_]

I wanted Vaan's outfit myself. Oddly surprised it's for SAM which I need the gear for. I grinded the new 24 man for one piece of it to the point I'm bored of it already because of greed rolls.

I am also confused over their creative choices with his outfit; his shirt which is clearly cloth is somehow leather, and his pants which are clearly leather in every other game are now weaver aligned and cloth (and also very poorly modelled)? :| Yes I am one of the 2 people out there that really liked Vaan. Come at me.

[Remedi]

Let's not forget about griefers

[SonKevin]

This is SE's way of making this content last. They don't actually want you to get armor for the alternate class you want. They want you to run it over and over and over again while you desperately try to win that roll for the class you want. It's disgusting.

[Catwho]

Alternate methods of implementing this that would have been better:

- Keep need but lock it to all your 70s only - or at the bare minimum you have to have the class unlocked and a soul stone equipped
- Keep need, but allow someone to pick one other class at the start besides the one they queued as
- Keep greed, but have a warning if you click it and you're not on a class that can equip it so people aren't making dumb mistakes (they do this on a lot of vendor gear so the code already exists!)

[CesarCouto]

no Need button = new players can't get armor from dungeons

[CesarCouto]

if the game don't have Need button = New Players or New character can't get armor from Dungeons

[Okamimaru]

I just got my NIN to 70, and my ilvl wasn't high enough to enter lighthouse, its nice that I can gear it to the point where I can run lighthouse with it using lighthouse. Isn't that the point of off jobs?

Could do that with need still there... I've done it...

[Lambdafish]

Could do that with need still there... I've done it...

Could, but this makes it easier. The point of the change is to aid people gearing their off jobs, including those that aren't a high enough ilvl to enter lighthouse, on that note it succeeds. I understand why people don't like the change, but I have yet to see any actual statistical evidence that this change is bad or has had any negative impact. People aren't mass rolling on loot, and people aren't trolling because they would only be able to do that once due to the weekly limit, and people like me with lower ilvl off jobs can freely loot on the gear we need.

The real reason this change exists is due to the JP culture of running their main for 24man content, which I think would benefit the west as well. Less deaths during the raid = better experience farming the loot piece you need.