Selfish DPS Balance

[Okamimaru]

I'd rather have a terrible nin or drg that does less damage than me and slightly buffs my dps with their poor cd timings than a terrible sam or blm that just does less damage than me.

A terrible DRG or NIN won't be using his buffs at all... hence them being terrible... off timed buffs is a mediocre player...

[Wayfinder3]

A terrible DRG or NIN won't be using his buffs at all... hence them being terrible... off timed buffs is a mediocre player...

except dragoons most potent buff is a combo, unfortuantely they'll still be pretty valuable

[Yeol]

This game has 9 damage dealers. The difference between the top (1st place) & bottom (9th place) dps is only 700. Which means that the higher you climb the list the lower the difference becomes among damage dealers. 700 dps difference is not much, and can easily be covered with raid buffs & much more. I would say that dealing 700 higher than the bottom dps is not what I expected from a pure damage dealer.
What I'd like to see is more diversity in damage, I don't want all damage dealers to be close in dps numbers.

At the moment, the jobs that gain most from raid buffs are actually the physical ranged. They bring big burst every 80s-60s. The rdps gain for them is still high even if you remove Disembowel from the calculation. When it should be about buffing your pure damage dealer. Sadly this will never happen until SE fixes the dps scale.

Fixing the dps scale includes all roles, not just damage dealers. It does not feel satisfying to me (As BRD) when I die or take damage down debuff to have a WAR pass me in dps. That is how close tanks dps is to the bottom dps. I want to feel like a damage dealer, I want feel satisfied by my damage.

I'd say make the difference between the bottom & top damage dealers much, much higher than 700. They should make it so that pure damage dealers are the ones that gain most from buffs and deal incredibly high numbers. Not like current meta where you select damage dealers from the middle/bottom of the list, and together they buff each other and gain more rdps than having a single pure dps that cannot match their buff gain or add much to rdps.

What we have now is way more flexible. Because all damage dealers dps numbers are relatively very close, and the boss HP is based on that. There is no damage dealer with insane high dps (Yet) that makes a difference in clearing content.
But flexible =/= balanced. If they want to keep dps numbers close to each-other, then they should remove pure dps idea from this game and rework SAM/BLM.

[Remedi]

But flexible =/= balanced. If they want to keep dps numbers close to each-other, then they should remove pure dps idea from this game and rework SAM/BLM.

While the idea of pure dps or healer jobs is enticing to me I also agree with you on the fact that if they want to keep this number balance they need to remove the idea of pure altogether

[lemon_qt]

It would be good if they made two kinds of synergies of meta-comp, to add diversity. The lack of job 'cheese' mechanics in raids is good for avoiding job stacking with DPS, however it does produce a cookie-cutter meta especially when it comes to speedkills.

For anyone reading, the current meta is as follows: PLD / WAR - AST / SCH - DRG / NIN - MCH / BRD (You might see a MNK / SMN within a speedkill comp as well). However, the biggest factor in all of this meta is the DRG piercing de-buff of 5% with disembowel. Perhaps, this de-buff needs to be removed and that would shake-up the meta.