First Time bonus - abandon?

[Akamadoshi]

Rude people will still be rude people, now they'll just abandon the instance themselves. I'm sorry this was your experience but that's no reason to force bad, intrusive game design on the rest of us. It's bad enough what they did with the MSQ dungeons.

Actually, this idea of mine would prevent. Imagine this: You are in a party of 8 man, one of them are new, in my case it was a mandervile - hillibrand cutscene! So of course it's a blast. But let us remain general; the cutscenes of dungeons/trials/raid aren't long, so basically my idea came to; if there is 1(or more, but importantly 1) is new and thus have cutscene, making party watch it to not leave the new player out, definitely puts an end to rude, impatient people and gives new players less paranoid feeling of being forced to skip. But this I recommend, if a player is new (everyone gets a bonus from the player, why not have consideration)? It is not meant as punishment, but resolve in my idea.

[BillyKaplan]

1) is new and thus have cutscene, making party watch it

There are ways to get around unskippable cutscenes so it doesn't really solve the problem. Also, as I said before, that's a bad idea and horrible design. Not everyone cares for the cutscenes and many have seen them numerous times. When you queue for DF you're going to get a mixed bag. If you want to avoid it, put up a PF. People will literally flock to the concept of bonus and as you said before you'd be watching cutscenes, no one'd give you a hard time for it.

[HyoMinPark]

if there is 1(or more, but importantly 1) is new and thus have cutscene, making party watch it to not leave the new player out, definitely puts an end to rude, impatient people and gives new players less paranoid feeling of being forced to skip.

Think about what you are asking: you are demanding that one group of people be forced into doing something...to prevent them from forcing another group of people into doing something. Shifting the force isn’t the answer to your predicament. Not everyone is impatient or a jerk; there are plenty of players that have zero issues with newbies watching cutscenes for things. You ran into a bad bunch; no need to punish everyone else because of a few.