Black magic...kinda sucks

[GunksFoy]

The way I was suggesting the degradation occur was that at the end of the timer, as it is now, you lose one stack then the others on three second timers. Thus you effectively extend the timer by six seconds for mechanics and those still learning the class while preserving the full power for those who have mastered it. Without driving the dps of the job into a brick wall as soon as the timer runs out. That way those who mastered the class still keep that mechanic as is, but while making the job slightly more forgiving for those still learning it, and thus a little more appealing.

This goes to show you don't understand the job. If you are EVER running out of AF/UI, you're doing it wrong. Transpose has already solved the issue that you are trying to fix here, and in a better way than what you suggest. There is no benefit to having 2 stacks over 1 except a small MP reduction. You already lose the speed buff from being in AF/UI3, so 1 stack vs 2 stacks is pointless. The is challenging, but this is not one of it's issues.

Everything you've posted so far just shows us that you do not understand the job or lack the ability to press Transpose every 8s. That's fine, play something else. But again, stop trying to ruin BLM for those who do enjoy.