Define a good player

[FelixDaCat]

Snipped

I think what it comes down to like others have mentioned, is what is a SKILLED player and what is a GOOD player. You can be one, without being the other and often people believe that being a really skilled/experienced player, automatically equals to that person being a good player. I think you can be a really good player, without having the skills/experience required to have done the hard/savage content in the game.

But it is a very subjective thing like you said, where there is many different interpretations of what counts in making you one. I think it's right to expect a certain standard from not just yourself, but the people you are in a party with. Normally when something is not going smoothly, it is a good player who is prepared to ask and listen to the other members "what am I doing wrong and how do I fix it?".