...Those are not just "potions" nor are they just "healing items". Before you use the terms "shallow comparison", I'd suggest actually looking at other games because honestly, you just showed that you haven't the faintest clue about what you're talking about here and if anything is shallow, it's your entire argument since you're using an idiom that has no weight or bearing on the conversation. You complained that XIV uses 5-10 items with the same icon, I gave you a game that recycles the same icon for multiple items way worse than what I'd consider XIV's sin to be.

But, clearly it definitely flew way over your head.