Please stop with the "no duplicates" and pigeon-holing our DPS into tiny windows

[AiharaMizuki]

While I understand this was designed to encourage greater class variety, it's also causing a lot of exclusion of popular classes.

How is it causing a lot of exclusion of popular classes? No duplicate jobs really only means no DUPLICATE jobs. Unless you're mistaking it for those PFs that doesn't allow certain classes to enter (plenty of SAM threads about it), the issue is not with "no duplicates job" nonsense.

It discourages people from playing the class they are most proficient at or simply enjoy playing the most.

Either look for another PF or start your own. It's been this way ever since the LB update.

2) Pigeon-holing our DPS into tiny windows

This is not a new thing. Classes have burst windows ever since ARR with the exception of Paladins and healers (except WHM).

machinist and monk I feel are far too rigid in their DPS demands.

So are other DPS classes. Can't have it too easy where you can just smash buttons and do amazing DPS.

Monk just seems like way too much concentration goes into timing everything precisely so that you end up with "squeeze all your DPS into this tiny window but only from this angle!

Again, every class have burst windows.

I feel like they really need to go back to the drawing board on those two classes.

Yes but for a different reason.