Thread: SCH 4.3 changes please

1. I am fine with Sacred Soil tbh. I would rather use my mp spamming miasma 2 instead of sacred soil. And it is only used in ultima attacks mostly. I barely use it in dungeons, unless tank is bad.
2. Deployment tactics 60 sec will make sch op, deploying crit shield every min is insane.
3. Whispering dawn lasts 30 sec. Do you want regen all the time? Then what's the point of fey union or for example, whm regen?
4. Again 6 stacks is too much. 3 stacks in 45 sec is already enough, i agree dissipation needs a poke though.
5. Again 120 potency dmg is higher than smn tribind. We already have an aoe miasma with a nice potency and dots. Silent dusk needs rework but not like that.
6. Passive ability? %5 would be nice but it is still a constant buff to party every min that lasts 30 sec.

It appears you want sch to fly to the moon. Tbh, i am happy with the sch right now except for couple of things but its heals aren't a problem.

I agree with Sacred Soil, its already on a 30s CD. I guess they could keep it on Aetherflow if the made the Succor proc higher, but as of right now making it oGCD sounds better.

I wanna say yes to DT but I see where it could be OP. Maybe 90s, split the difference.

Whispering Dawn is one of the few "perfect" skills, why do you want to change it.

Dissipation either needs a complete overhaul or just to resummon Lily. Personally, I still say it should be Scholar's version of Enkindle; we need to see Lily in her full form more, XD.

Silent Dusk is meh, good in theory, bad in execution. Selene is a support pet, why not a Direct Hit buff of 2% for 30s or so, call it Fey Resolve, maybe.

Fey Wind is fine for me

I wouldn't mind a slight CD reduction for Fey Caress. Maybe to 40, but 30 would be ideal. Feels like when eve I use it I need it again 10s later, T.T

Lev. 1 Fey Caress
Ability- 25 Sec Recast
Remove one detrimental status effect from a single party member.
Additional Effect: Restores HP. Cure Potency 200

Lev. 20 Clamoring Dusk
Spell - 2 Sec Cast/ 60 Sec Recast
Restore HP to all party members within 20 yalms.
Cure Potency 300.

Lev. 40 Fey Wind
Ability - 60 Sec Recast
Reduce both Weapon and Spell Cast/Recast Time and Auto Attack delay by 2% for 60 seconds.


A single Target Cleanse with a small touch of HP would make Selene so much more useful. She could be used in low level dungeons reliably and have slightly more impact with single target healing since the Cleanse could be used purely for its HP recovery between Embraces. Rouse would be effective for both pets due to Clamouring Dusk without stepping over Eos better HP recovery over time. Fey Wind would be a .5% buff increase but the continuous uptime would help to set the Scholar apart from the more powerful shortlived buffs from Astro.

Originally Posted by Eloah

... the Succor proc ...

Can someone tell me where I can get info on this? I noticed this proc but can't find anything in our traits or spells. Must've missed something.
NVM I'm an idiot.

All of those suggestions are just way too OP. Healers are like the one set of classes that are actually well balanced.

Sacred Soil is just fine where it is, unless you are DPSing too haphazardly or your party is just getting hit by multiple mechanics, there is no reason you shouldn't have the necessary Aetherflow stacks to pop Sacred Soil whenever you need. Deployment tactics is also good where it is to be able to Adlo shield the party every 60 seconds? Kiss healer balance goodbye. Same with Whispering Dawn, plus it fits nicely with Rouse at it's current CD, shortening it would be a bit of a pain. I wouldn't mind a change to Dissipation, but I believe yours is too lenient. You should be penalized for using it by not immediately having your fairy return. That said, I do wish the rewards were a bit greater for that sacrifice. I... don't even know what to say about a damaging Silent Dusk. Call me set in my ways, butt Fairies should not being doing damage directly or indirectly. I suppose I could see a 2% increase to Fey Wind, but I'd rather just see a rework of Selene to make her more support oriented overall.

I'd change succor to be a slightly faster cast time. Can be annoying trying to get the shields up before a raid wide hit goes out.

Maybe extend shadow flares duration again.

And add an auto resummon to dissipation and make the healing potency buff affect everything. Including lustrate and indomnobility.

I'd completely revamp the fairy system to make it use the aetherpact gauge at all levels as I've said in other threads.

NO

Stop wanting scholar to be a god.
Learn how to play it instead.