The Fashion Report

[Vespar]

Wow, the pts from the ring must be a huge deal because I got 4/5 gold. the only thing that I didnt have was a halonic ring. Everything else I scored gold coins on. My score was 79 -___-;

Jeebus! That seems a bit strict! I have one more shot at it, but I dont think I wanna do the Vault just for a ring but I guess I will have to if I want an 80 or higher.
---------------------
Update:
Here's what I used and scored an 85 on my last attempt.

Song Bird Hat - dyed Pure White (this one doesnt need to be dyed it seems but mine already was)
Falconer's Shirt NQ - dyed Pure White
Plain Long Skirt NQ - dyed Jet Black
Bridesmaid's Shoes NQ - dyed Metallic Gold
Halonic Conservator's Ring (obtained from The Vault - any Halonic ring will work)
Remaining slots were filled using my WHM gear set (Make sure you have some kind of gear in every slot or it will deduct points)

All of this resulted in 5/5 Gold (max points)

[Niqote]

It seems that colour was a big influence. using the much cheaper Snow white dye is getting very good results in the reddit thread, just like pure white dye.

And your other slots, though not judged still count.

[swiss_Momo]

well, looking at some Japanese sites for shoes the spring dress shoes or artisan sandals dyed honey yellow seem to give gold rating too.

[Sentaryuu]

Is there any other ring that will work? I have neither from dusk vigil or vault?

[Fuyuzora]

Is there any other ring that will work? I have neither from dusk vigil or vault?

why not just run dusk vigil unsync? the first boss chest can give rings, i got mine first run and you can just leave after the first boss and start over.

[DevonEllwood]

Got an 86 ^_^ I thought that if you got a high score the boutique might get some glamour items but guess not

What shirt is that? I'm too late to jump on the falconer shirt train and I can't craft one myself.

EDIT:
Also need to figure out what to do for the shoes. Artisan sandals are also not going to work. I really just need to get my crafting levels up.

[Yamimarik]

Dang! I should've held on to my last try longer >.< lol.

Someone on Reddit FINALLY FOUND A SHOE that males can wear to get a gold rating on it... and he got 90 as a score!

• Hat - Royal Senecshal's Chapeau ( snow white )
• Chest - Falconer's Shirt ( snow white )
• Legs - Asuran Hakama of Healing ( soot black )
• Boots - Artisan's Sandals ( Metallic Gold )
• Ring - Dusk Vigil Ring.

https://www.reddit.com/r/ffxiv/comme...ckin/?sort=new

[Osteichthyes]

Okay, massive problem that I can see is that the gauges for how each piece is scored is not clear, or not useful in which case they should not be there. Going from something that under no circumstance matches the criteria to something that may does not seem to have an effect and it not clear as to why this occurs. The feedback definitely needs to be clearer. It's a decent start, but needs a little more UX work.

[Rymm]

What shirt is that? I'm too late to jump on the falconer shirt train and I can't craft one myself.

It's the Hannish Wool Autumn Shirt and on most servers it's gonna be about a million times more expensive than the falconer's.

[Osteichthyes]

Additionally, it would be nice to continue getting appraised even if you can no longer get a high score just to see how the different results vary.