Thread: Monk 4.2 Adjustments

Originally Posted by Kaimishi

...

While SMN is not a Swiss Army Knife of support like NIN, BRD or PLD. Shiroe was pointing out how SMN and MNK are akin to BLM and SAM and should be on the a similar 2nd best personal DPS with utility. However, SMN has much more to contribute overall to the team vs MNK, this is without considering your points on not affecting your personal performance as SMN, which we could also argue the same for MNK but that would be moot if we're honest. Brotherhood is still limited by damage type (5% physical ATK, casters get nothing) vs Devotion (2% ATK, 2% DEF, 5% HEAL Magic) buff. And Mantra while being much stronger for healing it doesn't do much of helping healers with an incoming attack ever so often.

MNK is (or was) a Swiss Army Knife... of personal survival, but that also sacrifices our personal performance.