Quote Originally Posted by winsock View Post
I disagree. We are pushing this conversation more and more into the abstract (and honestly i think this is becoming a pretty interesting discussion as it becomes more abstract). To push it further, do circumstances matter at all?

John is a level 70 tank and queues for sastasha. It's his first time tanking a dungeon.
Jane is a level 15 tank and queues for sastasha. It's her first time tanking a dungeon.

For all intents and purposes, assume they are equally terrible. How should they be treated?
No, you can not abstract this. Its impossible. Sastasha as an entry level dungeon will always provide a different challenge than a high level dungeon, seeing as how the entry level dungeon has simpler mechanics and the player has to deal with less skills. You literally cannot compare these two, not even in an abstract way.