why not have repeatable version of the story quests?

[BillyKaplan]

I'm not saying it's not a good idea but nor am I saying that we should just cater to any whimsical thought that someone has. I'm sure if there's enough support by adding your thoughts to it in game as well as the forums then maybe depending on the amount of work that needs to be done, might actually get done.

I fail to get your point. On one hand you're saying they can't please everyone, on the other hand you're saying 'well if there's enough support...' which is exactly what this thread is for, making people stop to think about it and, should they agree they want it, upvote it or reply in the thread. No one makes a post in the forum thinking Yoshi-P is going to hand down a royal decree telling the development team to stop doing anything else and only implement their suggestion, but how else are we supposed to even have a chance at it?

[Shouko]

I fail to get your point. On one hand you're saying they can't please everyone, on the other hand you're saying 'well if there's enough support...' which is exactly what this thread is for, making people stop to think about it and, should they agree they want it, upvote it or reply in the thread. No one makes a post in the forum thinking Yoshi-P is going to hand down a royal decree telling the development team to stop doing anything else and only implement their suggestion, but how else are we supposed to even have a chance at it?

How is that confusing? Just because you add something into the game doesn't mean that every single person asked for it or even want it.

People make these request threads thinking their idea is going to be heard after all in your own words that's exactly what you just said.

There's an in game suggestion that you can use that goes straight to the devs, unlike the forums which are more likely to fall on deaf ears so to speak.

[BillyKaplan]

There's an in game suggestion that you can use that goes straight to the devs, unlike the forums which are more likely to fall on deaf ears so to speak.

That's not what the in-game suggestion function is for



The in-game suggestion is about their in-game support. You'd see they themselves tell people to go to the forums to leave suggestions about the game.
It makes zero sense for people to send suggestions directly to the devs. The forum is a much better system for that because they can see how much support an idea actually can get, instead of every single person sending their personal niche request. If it gets enough support, the forum reps pass it along. If it doesn't, at least it doesn't waste the devs' time.