Quote Originally Posted by akaneakki View Post
They wouldn't if dps requirement would be lets say 5k each dps, or slightly lower, this is without healer dps and tanks doing a lot. Then last dps is at 2.5k dps or 3k. They could do it if both healers did 1k dps. But you know how the community works, dps healers = nothx. Tanks are tanks so spam aggro combo. If all 4 had 5k dps it been a easily clear, but lets wrap it around and say all 4 of them had 2.5k dps, would they clear? Nope.
Yes, if the DPS requirement is 5k personal DPS from each of the 4 DPS and someone isn't hitting that then yes they are underperforming and either need to improve or leave the group. Could the healers make up for it? Yes, but I would consider that being carried since the DPS isn't doing at least their share of the work.

And yes, your second example none would clear as none of them are meeting even the minimum DPS requirement. I can agree with you there, even though that is far from the situation I was arguing.