Tank Stances, Traited

[MauvaisOeil]

Yours is not fixing, it's amputating one big portion of the tank community.

Considering that what you jabber shows that you have no idea what the real issue is and how to properly fix something without pissing off everyone, I actually don't care about your opinion.

I wouldn't agree : His/her fix is the core of the problem about tanks : The passive defense on gear is enough to survive anything. To avoid having to scale to tremendous damage the mobs/bosses of dungeons, the more logical fix would be to tone this passive amount down and increase the efficiency of the stance to match the previous tankability, but with stance dependance.

That's pretty much what I already suggested, damage should not be tuned up, only passive resistance down. Because what makes tanks able to survive content withouth stance is not tied to the sole usage of cooldown and burst damage, but to the high resistance tanks already have just wearing gear.

[Reynhart]

I wouldn't agree : His/her fix is the core of the problem about tanks : The passive defense on gear is enough to survive anything.

That's not the problem. The problem is only what DPS the raid loses by having a tank using its stance.
And by making tanks unable to survive out of tank stance, you're just forcing turtle tanking upon every player, which will piss off a lot of people, and only shift the "only efficient playstyle".

That's pretty much what I already suggested, damage should not be tuned up, only passive resistance down.

I acknowledged four pages ago that you don't necessarily have to increase damage received. And never suggested that you should to the point of making the stance mandatory.