im confused then haha , but I just hate how much a fav job of mine is getting hate, it could be in a better spot for sure but it isnt like horrible like all these threads are suggesting


This isn't hate, its love. We love the job that's why we're pointing out how screwed it is, we want it to get attention.
It's not hate we're all upset that SE hasn't addressed Drks glaring problems this xpac where Wars have had tons of love and tweaks and Pld is just all around a better Drk with better damage and utility. We want our favorite class to shine, as does everyone including the person that posted about Monks, which is very true, we love Drk and want it to get the attention it deserves.


PLD in Heavensward was nowhere near as bad as DRK is in Stormblood.
In Heavensward PLD was better than DRK in Physical fights given their unique kit to handle physical damage alongside their natural shield blocks and as well as their potentially permanent 10% str down. It was not optimal, but it was an option they possessed that had a significant defensive effect. Alongside that, their CD kit has also remained unchanged with the role skills system. If anything, their kit has been boosted with the ability to now block magic damage as well as the introduction of their 3 unique new defensive tools, Passage of Arms, Intervention and boosted Cover.
In Heavensward, PLD had 3 skills over DRK in RoH, Sheltron and Bulwark. Whilst DRK had 2 over PLD in Magical fights with Dark Mind and Delirium. Why DRK was taken over PLD was because of it's superior damage and Delirium(and Reprisal) was way more useful than Divine Veil was for Raid Wide damage.
Come SB and DRK literally lost most of their skills to the Role System with no way of recovering their skills back in their old forms AND only gained a shallow gauge mechanic with 3 abilities that only somewhat patched the gaping hole in their damage.
PLD in SB deals more damage, has more raid-wide utility by miles, and has a better self CD kit.
3.0
PLD
Uni CD: 3 (Rampart, Sentinel, Hallowed Ground)
Situ CD: 3 (Bulwark, Sheltron, Rage of Halone)
Fluff CD: 0
Raid Support: 2 (Divine Veil, Clemency)
Situ Raid Support: 1 (Cover)
Total options: 9
DRK:
Uni CD: 4 (Shadowskin, ShadowWall, Living Dead, Reprisal)
Situ CD: 1 (Dark Mind)
Fluff CD: 1 (Dark Dance)
Raid Support: 2 (Reprisal, Delirium)
Total options: 8
=============================
4.0
PLD
Uni CD: 6 (Rampart, Sentinel, Hallowed Ground, Sheltron, Bulwark, Passage of Arms)
Situ CD: 0
Fluff CD: 0
Raid Support: 5 (Intervention, Cover, Divine Veil, Clemency, Passage of Arms)
Total options: 12
DRK:
Uni CD: 4 (Rampart, Shadowwall, Living Dead, The Blackest Night)
Situ CD: 1 (Dark Mind)
Fluff CD: 0
Raid Support: 1 (The Blackest Night)
Total options: 6
TLR
PLD had issues that could simply be circumvent by not playing poorly i.e one perma main tank whilst also giving back to their team. It even excelled in fights that weren't mindlessly catered to DRK.
DRK has no redeeming qualities in SB. It is harder to play for no greater reward, gets slapped around under regular auto damage, and has no clear optimization path because of the poorly adjusted potencies and balance between Blood and Mana, has legitimately dead skills on its hotbar, it's only single support now is TBN, and has to use it's main resource for either Defense or Offense.
DRK now, is truly garbage in comparison to even 3.0 PLD.
That's a HUGE difference holy crap glad you brought that up that we're down to 6 vs PLDs mega 12 I hope SE realizes this, also can you edit into War as well?
Posts like these really make me want to level my DK... Have warrior at 70, and dk and paladin at 60.... Goin to level one of them next, and the forums have actually convinced me to level Dark knight....Alot of really good feedback here, and honestly I'd be surprised if at least some of these suggestions doesnt make it live... All I can say is the quality of life changes made to warrior are great.... Especially the ones made to shake it off...
As far as I can tell in SB, paladins are great, warriors are also great at the moment, leaving dk the only tank job....Pretty sure they'll have a look at that next....


Nice in you, DRK is in a horrible state and SE needs to hear you guys.
I only wish Monks were as loud...
Monk was my first DPS class in HW I leveled up to 60, and I finished to level it to 70 3/4 days ago.
While its damage is mostly fine compared to other DPS contrary to DRK compared to other Tank, it shares the same problems of being noticibly harder to play to have the same result (I also got my Samurai to 70). Tackle Mastery is a total joke, RoE is disapointing and also makes TK more undesirable as of now (which is unchanged, another disapointement) and RoF feels sooooo slow. Concerning Deep Meditation and Brotherhood, I like the idea behind, to play more with chakras, but there is two problems : 1, we only use it on forbidden chakra, purification is useless now that Monk basically have infinite TP, why not add more chakra skills ? ; and 2, it's composition and luck dependant.You got a caster heavy party ? Well, you're out of luck. And even without composition, it's RNG dependant, so when parsing, doing the exact same performance on how you play, the numbers varies heavily depending on your luck with procing chakras.
I'm focusing to DRK right now as it's my Main, but Monk is not fine on a playstyle level. Sad for what was at first "Monk expansion" (but it isn't, it's Samurai expansion). So you have my sympathy, and I hope it'll get fixed alongside DRK.

I'm gonna join this protest too.
Currently levelling my Warrior but leaving my beloved DK behind really break my heart.
Besides all the problem on the individual skill, and the weak one without any reason (pointing at you living dead), the worst part is that DK is not fun anymore.
Outside AOE environment, the single target tanking became boring and lackluster.
on top of that my static run with 3 ranged 1 drg meele static, due to preferences on job playstyle. So i've no reason to trade off the slashing debuff, the warrior dps AND the raid mitigation utility that warrior now offer.
Last edited by Mattiux; 10-20-2017 at 07:24 PM.
Not that it changes the conclusion but you can’t just look at the # of skills to compare their options.
TBN alone is a weaker alternative to intervention, cover and even clemency (i.e. raises your eHP in a different way). Due to the short CD, it can cover scenarios where you’d need multiple skills from other jobs.
For every situation PLD uses cover/intervention/clemency, DRK can use TBN as a weaker alternative.
|
|
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
|
|
Cookie Policy
This website uses cookies. If you do not wish us to set cookies on your device, please do not use the website. Please read the Square Enix cookies policy for more information. Your use of the website is also subject to the terms in the Square Enix website terms of use and privacy policy and by using the website you are accepting those terms. The Square Enix terms of use, privacy policy and cookies policy can also be found through links at the bottom of the page.

Reply With Quote
R




