First-Annual "Why is This STILL Not a Thing"

[Slirith]

I just want to be able to tell who rolls need/greed/pass before the rolls happen.

[Joven]

Another Gil sink.

A quick idea off the top of my head is to be able to exchange gil for mogstation currency, but not vice versa.

The exchange rate would have to be horrendously one-sided in favor of Mogstation to keep players from simply buying out everything they want in one go. I do like the idea a lot though

[Jas710]

I just want to be able to tell who rolls need/greed/pass before the rolls happen.

- Loot windows that display a checked list of players who rolled and who hasn't yet.

[Antonio_Xul]

Another one I thought about is a "Repair All" button that actually repairs all items damaged instead the way it is, section by section.

[ThunderGodThor]

The exchange rate would have to be horrendously one-sided in favor of Mogstation to keep players from simply buying out everything they want in one go. I do like the idea a lot though

I honestly don't see why- the mogstation is a terrible thing in a p2p game anyway. At least it will make the content available for everyone fairly, as it should be since the content is paid for with subs anyway.

[Keridwyn]

- Removal of vote kick system. If there's a problem player, everyone drops regardless of progress.

Wait, are you serious here? So if there's one problem player instead of removing the person causing the issue the three people who didn't have an issue should give up progress and start again? Yeah, nobody ever is going to abuse that.

[Joven]

I honestly don't see why- the mogstation is a terrible thing in a p2p game anyway. At least it will make the content available for everyone fairly, as it should be since the content is paid for with subs anyway.

As long as it's not Pay to Win items I see nothing wrong with having optional purchasable items outside the game itself. If the prices are reasonable and people are willing to pay for it, I say go for it. The key word is optional, if the content was available fairly to everyone then they might as well just give it to you in game. For some that would just be a bother of more inventory space taken. If it was an optional quest or something like that, then that would be a fair distribution for those who want and those who don't.

[Jeycht]

Is this a problem in OTHER mmo's?

I don't know I haven't play any other MMO since I'm on FF. btw it's not the point, in other MMO or not it's still an issue here.
I have seen enough people kicking other just to invite a friend for the last boss.

[Dark-Saviour]

Of the already-mentioned things, Glamour Log and ability to do actions while mounted (talking, abandoning leves, etc) would be good.
Also:
Instanced housing plots (not apartments)
Making all gear dyeable from the start (stop creating duplicate sets that can simply be dyed)
Desummoning and Stabling the chocobo in one step or the ability to temporarily stable it for training without desummoning it.
Improved Mega-FATE scaling and incentives for older content.

[Kaelah]

Auto pass on loot you already own that is unique.