Okay, I stand corrected. I haven't done PvP (nor been to the pier) on any other class besides MNK since they added the new system so I was mistaken. It would somewhat "work" for certain classes in PvE. I'm still not entirely sure why anyone would want to just mash ~3 buttons over and over again. It only really works in PvP because neutering or outright removing a bunch of skills makes for very simplistic rotations which lend themselves to PvP's dynamic nature. In PvE I think the same treatment would make combat incredibly boring.

So again: No, thank you.