Quote Originally Posted by Dzian View Post
I use them as and when needed.

I personally hate tanks that use them when not needed or at the wrong times

for example if you're down to 25k hp losing roughly 1k a second and the current pull will be dead in 15 seconds It's not worth using a cooldown at all. the pack will be dead before you are.. and the passive regen between pulls mean you wont even need much healing. especially if im on scholar my cos you won't even stress my fairy.. if the dps is a bit naff and the pull gonna take 35-40 seconds then sure use a cool down..
You speak of optimization, and I totally get you. You don't have to use your CDs just because they are available, and you also have to factor their CD duration. You use them when the situation requires you to use them. An example for a healer would be their MP regen, or healing potency buffs. Should I still use them, even if I don't need them, just because they are available? That's hardly optimal.

When there is synergy between the tank and healer, it makes things a blast for the DPS as well, and you get a well-oiled dungeon mower. Both misuse and no use of CDs make this synergy very difficult to obtain. Varying playstyles along with runs done in silence already make coordinated efforts from players tough enough, adding poor CD usage to it creates a lot of strain for the other members in the group.

As a healer with little tanking experience, I am not going to notice if tanks are optimizing their CD usage. In all honesty, I'm not even looking to see if they're using them. I'm constantly looking at your HP gauge and looking for damage, and looking for icons pointing down. The thing is, if we're in an intense fight and your health continues to dip towards zero, it's because I am also in trouble and trying to keep myself alive. What irks healers like me, is when the tank isn't doing anything to help me out in this situation.

It's times like that when I DO notice the tank does not have mitigation buffs up, is in offensive stance, etc. I still don't point fingers. Maybe his abilities are still on CD. Maybe he totally thought he was in the appropriate stance, but in fact was not and just didn't notice in time (happened to me countless times when cleric was with us). All I can hope for is that he is similar to myself, and simply looks for what they could have done better.