Page 9 of 10 FirstFirst ... 7 8 9 10 LastLast
Results 81 to 90 of 106

Hybrid View

  1. #1
    Player
    Thoro39's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2015
    Posts
    67
    Character
    Thoro Heavypunch
    World
    Phoenix
    Main Class
    Monk Lv 60
    Quote Originally Posted by Mycow8me View Post
    I dont understand why ppl are so worried about it. If your group needs the extra DPS from a tank spending as much time as it can not intank stance while maintanking... Their might be other issues. When your tanking the boss stay in your tank stance if u want. If your off tanking or waiting till next tank swap, take it off and deeps your heart out. If you want to experience some risk vs reward ask your healers if you can try staying out of tank stance as much as possible. See what works. You staying in tank stance and mitigating as much as possible might be allowing the healers to dps more.
    The difference between a good player and an average-complacent player is that the former readily accepts to carry parties through these "other issues" into a clear, while the latter just sits in tankstance and tells others that these issues are "not his problem" since he's tanking just fine, all while wiping repeatedly. Obviously any kind of advice should recommend good play, that helps any party, so the former is recommended while the latter should be avoided.

    On the last sentence, there are plenty of instances in savage fights where the boss stops autoattacking( i.e. do 0 damage specifically to the tank) for a minute or more in O3S and many more fights, and in these instances, Tankstance is nothing but a disadvantage.
    The "your healers might dps more" argument is also flawed, as it pushes the responsibility to deal DPS while doing their roleduties to the healers. Why should Healers dps when you as a tank do not bother to improve your DPS through stancedancing? That's a doublestandard.
    In addition, the "extra heals" that a no-tankstance tank requires are much less of a dps loss than a full tankstance tank. A full tankstance tank deals up to 40~60% less damage than a proper dps tank, and it's enough damage loss to make fights harder for your party.

    Harder? How? Aren't Tankstance Tanks supposed to be safe? Let me elaborate.
    A properly played dps-oriented-party can afford 7 or more playerdeaths while still comfortably clearing the O3S-O4S enrage timer, while a party with fulltankstance tanks has a muuch lower leeway in clearing the enrage time, some parties even have to give up and wipe/reset after one single dps death. In the case of O3S and O4S, it means that a proper high dps party also has the luxury to use two heal LB3's instead of DPS LB3s to save a party without fearing the enrage timer.
    The former then can therefore afford many more mistakes than the latter, while the latter requires perfect mechanical execution. So even if the full tank-stance Tanks play "safe", the party itself is at a much greater pressure and risk to play mechanically perfectly. That pressure to not be able to afford one single death or two on itself is an unsafe disadvantage.
    Many, many times, I hear people say "We just dont have get a death", whenever they die to the enrage timer. It's one solution, but an easier solution is to deal more damage in the first place through proper good play with good rotation, including the tanks, so that any kind of deaths are not an issue in the first place when it comes to clearing a fight before the enrage timer.

    It's how good parties clear difficult fights early, as learning a new fight to the extent of perfection always takes a certain time, while learning a proper opener/rotation and a general feel on when to stancedance as a tank is more of one-and-done instance that you have to learn only one time and then continue to apply and slightly adjust to every fight in the future, enabling your party to clear many battles before achieving/learning mechanical perfection for each specifically.
    (1)
    Last edited by Thoro39; 09-29-2017 at 06:00 PM.

  2. #2
    Player
    MauvaisOeil's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2017
    Posts
    297
    Character
    Jaghatai Dotharl
    World
    Ragnarok
    Main Class
    Dark Knight Lv 70
    Quote Originally Posted by Thoro39 View Post
    The difference between a good player and an average-complacent player is that the former is readily accepts to carry parties through these "other issues", while the latter just sits in tankstance and tells others that these issues are "not his problem" since he's tanking just fine. Obviously any kind of advice should recommend good play, that helps any party, so the former is recommended while the latter should be avoided.

    On the last sentence, there are plenty of instances in savage fights where the boss stops autoattacking( i.e. do 0 damage specifically to the tank) for a minute or more in O3S and many more fights, and in these instances, Tankstance is nothing but a disadvantage.
    The "your healers might dps more" argument is also flawed, as it pushes the responsibility to deal DPS while doing their roleduties to the healers. Why should Healers dps when you as a tank do not bother to improve your DPS through stancedancing? That's a doublestandard.
    In addition, the "extra heals" that a no-tankstance tank requires are much less of a dps loss than a full tankstance tank. A full tankstance tank deals up to 40~60% less damage than a proper dps tank, and it's enough damage loss to make fights harder for your party.

    Harder? How? Aren't Tankstance Tanks supposed to be safe? Let me elaborate.
    A properly played dps-oriented-party can afford 7 or more playerdeaths while still comfortably clearing the O3S-O4S enrage timer, while a party with fulltankstance tanks has a muuch lower leeway in clearing the enrage time, some even parties have to give up after one single dps death. The former then can therefore afford many more mistakes than the latter, while the latter requires perfect mechanical execution. So even if the full tank-stance Tanks play "safe", the party itself is at a much greater pressure and risk to play mechanically perfectly. That pressure to not be able to afford one single death or two on itself is an unsafe disadvantage.
    Many, many times, I hear people say "We just dont have get a death", whenever they die to the enrage timer. It's one solution, but an easier solution is to deal more damage in the first place through proper good play with good rotation, including the tanks, so that any kind of deaths are not an issue in the first place when it comes to clearing a fight before the enrage timer.
    Turning around the problem into "player's bad mind and refusal of responsabilities" won't change the fact it's a poor designed thing ATM. Some enjoy it, some don't, like pretty much everything on every subject and every situation, that's fine. But the core idea of tank stances, beeing "serious" role defining abilities obtained at lvl 30 supposed to define the core function of your job from the moment you obtain it, to your last breath (might be quite close actually), is a failure.

    Some define it as skill, while it's a matter of party synergy more than individual skill. Some consider the tank stance is a babysit, other as a supposed allways on move.

    The fact is, the game forked somewhere, somehow. When rezzes can be done up to seven times withouth failing a fight, when 100% dps stance uptime is achieved, where is supposed to be a hard bargain to deal with. It's tank and spank with acceptable failure around every corner. If the only difficulty SE can put in a fight is "Enrage timer" to ensure only a restricted amount of playerbase will ensure a kill, there is obviously a serious lack of imagination and long term sight here.

    Now as some said (shinko, I believe), stances and IB are a thing of the past, which simply shows the poor ability of game devs to keep abilities mandatory and valuable with expansions passing by. Pretty dumb imo, to make things into making not only older content, but older skills and spells, less and less relevant.
    (2)

  3. #3
    Player
    Mycow8me's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2013
    Posts
    1,057
    Character
    Tolby Seyfert
    World
    Cactuar
    Main Class
    Blacksmith Lv 70
    Quote Originally Posted by Thoro39 View Post
    The difference between a good player and an average-complacent player is that the former readily accepts to carry parties through these "other issues" into a clear, while the latter just sits in tankstance and tells others that these issues are "not his problem" since he's tanking just fine, all while wiping repeatedly. Obviously any kind of advice should recommend good play, that helps any party, so the former is recommended while the latter should be avoided.
    I dont want to argue with you but for the record... In general I think everyone should strive to do their best but what works well for one person/party may not work well for another. You could accept that their may be other issues and "carry" the party by pushing yourself but there are limits and even if there wasn't... you could elaborate on those other problems and not carry the party and everyone function better "as a whole". I think that is what a "good player" would be doing.
    (0)
    Last edited by Mycow8me; 09-29-2017 at 10:09 PM.

  4. #4
    Player
    Kerrath's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2013
    Posts
    46
    Character
    Kerrath Ellouelle
    World
    Mateus
    Main Class
    Marauder Lv 70
    Quote Originally Posted by Mycow8me View Post
    I dont want to argue with you but for the record... In general I think everyone should strive to do their best but what works well for one person/party may not work well for another. You could accept that their may be other issues and "carry" the party by pushing yourself but there are limits and even if there wasn't... you could elaborate on those other problems and not carry the party and everyone function better "as a whole". I think that is what a "good player" would be doing.
    what?

    the optimal way to play a tank right now is to sit in dps stance, bottom line. the benefits of tank stance are negligible and the penalties of tank stance are massive. It has nothing to do with other players in your party. A 'good player' strives to perform the best they can, and so by extension, a 'good tank' learns how to properly tank in dps stance.
    (0)

  5. #5
    Player
    Sarcatica's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2015
    Posts
    663
    Character
    Sarcatica Lin
    World
    Tonberry
    Main Class
    Dark Knight Lv 70
    Quote Originally Posted by Kerrath View Post
    what?

    the optimal way to play a tank right now is to sit in dps stance, bottom line. the benefits of tank stance are negligible and the penalties of tank stance are massive. It has nothing to do with other players in your party. A 'good player' strives to perform the best they can, and so by extension, a 'good tank' learns how to properly tank in dps stance.
    Depends on the parties. I tend to tone the "dps stance all the way" approach when I am helping a group trying to clear or progress. The premises of dps stance tanking is much more appealing when you know the game more and you know the healers are capable. This is why it's very hard to just know if someone is really a good tank or if that person just wants to dps and don't know how to adjust to the team he/she is with. This also applies to healers and also DPS believe it or not. Good players are people that know how to push their limits in the given situations. You don't just get that same dps when you are playing other groups.

    Example: each group has different players and it means that you have different total dps. As a DPS player, you need to account for phase changes, burst times etc to have the most dps. I have seen so many dps having 95%++ on fflogs but when that dps joins my team as a sub, their performance went down by a good amount. Why? Mostly because they are so used to their own killing time that it would take more time for them to adjust to our time (faster kills). This applies double to tanks and healers on different groups where they probably need to heal more or be in tank stance more etc, on top of their centralized dps rotations.
    (2)
    Last edited by Sarcatica; 09-30-2017 at 07:59 PM.

  6. #6
    Player
    Quri's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2017
    Posts
    52
    Character
    Quri Visqi
    World
    Sargatanas
    Main Class
    Warrior Lv 100
    The tank meta ain't all that hard, you and your group needs to know the fight as the requirement. If you or either anyone in your group don't know the fight, stay in tank stance if main tank. Though ridding of damage penalty for tank stance would be a fine addition though DRK might be stuck as Main tank, as it is, there's no reason to not be in a stance.
    (1)

  7. #7
    Player
    aleph_null's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2016
    Posts
    690
    Character
    Aleph Alpha
    World
    Tonberry
    Main Class
    Warrior Lv 80
    The underlying issue here is that tank stance comes at a dps cost, while other mitigation skills, excluding TBN and IB, do not. Now given that premise, if you have a surplus of mitigation, obviously the first thing you "want" to reduce is tank stance uptime, simple as that. They need to give us reasons to not want to reduce tank stance uptime, which basically means the healers must contribute more extra dps than what we gain from switching to dps stance, though in that case we're just shifting the burden to maximize dps to them, and they can complain over that as well.

    Another possible reason to make us not want to drop tank stance is to make it impossible to survive in dps stance, but that has problems as well. As I said above, if there is a surplus of mitigation, you'd give up the ones that cost you more first, in this case the tank stance. So you need to make sure that the "free" mitigation tools like rampart, vengeance etc aren't enough to mitigate incoming damage, but tank stance is. Now if you make it absolutely necessary to use tank stance AND all those free mitigation tools (.e. no surplus of mitigation) to clear contents, you'd get people complaining that tanking is too hard. Let's face it, if the tanks in Angered, Rushers etc need to be in tank stance to survive, even considering their exceptional healers and party members, your average PF tanks won't live.

    If you want to give some leeway for average players, there needs to be a surplus of mitigation, if you want tank stance to not be considered a surplus, you need to either make the free mitigations much weaker than tank stance (in which case they might as well not exist), or make them no longer free (i.e. every single mitigation skill comes at the cost of some resource/dps/uptime, and they must cost more than what tank stances cost). In the latter case they just become the new "tank stance" and people will avoid them outside progression.

    Tbh considering how the devs want to reduce the skill gap between good players and average players, they might as well remove tank/dps stances from all tank jobs, just like how they removed cleric stance dancing from healers.
    (1)

  8. #8
    Player
    gti443's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2013
    Posts
    60
    Character
    Amphelice Shepard
    World
    Siren
    Main Class
    Red Mage Lv 70
    Quote Originally Posted by aleph_null View Post
    which basically means the healers must contribute more extra dps than what we gain from switching to dps stance, though in that case we're just shifting the burden to maximize dps to them, and they can complain over that as well.
    I would... kinda love that as White Mage TBH.

    I would actually prefer a wider gulf between tank and DPS stance though. My ideal would be something like turtle in tank stance with more in the way of group DPS buffs, while pretty much zero survivability in DPS stance but higher potential DPS. Not true DPS numbers but close(r).
    (0)

  9. #9
    Player
    aleph_null's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2016
    Posts
    690
    Character
    Aleph Alpha
    World
    Tonberry
    Main Class
    Warrior Lv 80
    Quote Originally Posted by gti443 View Post
    I would... kinda love that as White Mage TBH.

    I would actually prefer a wider gulf between tank and DPS stance though. My ideal would be something like turtle in tank stance with more in the way of group DPS buffs, while pretty much zero survivability in DPS stance but higher potential DPS. Not true DPS numbers but close(r).
    In that case you'll just see a similar thread in the healer forum, where "pure healers" don't like how their healing skills are underused and they want tanks to take more damage to make their heals relevant lol.

    The thing is, with how the devs want savage to be more accessible, you can't really expect stuffs that are actually hard to tank/heal. If you make the mitigation/healing checks too tight we'll get another gordias savage, except people now struggle with different things than dps checks. The only place where we can hope to see actually hard stuffs would be the new super savage or ultimate, whatever they call it, since that fight is tuned for max ilv, so technically the devs can tune it such that you'll need every single mitigation/healing tools you have, including tank stances, to survive.

    I honestly think it's pointless to keep tank stance penalties, since this game is centered around vertical progression, so a surplus of mitigation/ehp is guaranteed to exist (raids drop gear that are better than the minimum gear you need to clear them). At higher ilv tanks will need less mitigation to survive, healers will need less healing to keep people alive, so naturally they'll cut off the stuffs that come at a cost (tank stance, gcd heals) as much as they can.
    (1)
    Last edited by aleph_null; 10-01-2017 at 03:14 AM.

  10. #10
    Player
    gti443's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2013
    Posts
    60
    Character
    Amphelice Shepard
    World
    Siren
    Main Class
    Red Mage Lv 70
    Quote Originally Posted by aleph_null View Post
    In that case you'll just see a similar thread in the healer forum, where "pure healers" don't like how their healing skills are underused and they want tanks to take more damage to make their heals relevant lol.
    Yeah... that genie isn't going back into the bottle. Moreover, there's more times you're not going to need a heal than times when you don't need a tank.

    Tangentially, Cleric was like a lvl 12 Conjurer cross skill, where stances are presented as core Job abilities. Like I said in the other thread, a revamp to stances would probably have to be closer to the changes to Bard songs and Machinist turrets.

    At higher ilv tanks will need less mitigation to survive, healers will need less healing to keep people alive, so naturally they'll cut off the stuffs that come at a cost (tank stance, gcd heals) as much as they can.
    I mean what I'm suggesting isn't intended to kill stance dancing as much as make it higher risk and potentially higher burst, while not inherently making it a DPS loss to stay in stance. It would be a boon to OT as well, but I guess it would pretty much demand dancing for OT busters.

    I dunno... I get that people like the "reward" but I don't think the current situation is tenable and for what it matters from FFXI til now I've basically been a career MMO tank and healer. I guess my horse in this race is that a lot of the current metas are sort of driving me away from both.
    (0)
    Last edited by gti443; 10-01-2017 at 07:23 AM.

Page 9 of 10 FirstFirst ... 7 8 9 10 LastLast