I can't comment on WoW's PvP as I've never played it. I imagine it's good, at least from things I've heard.

My only issue is when people bash on PvP in this game, because it's the popular thing to do, or simply because of what they've heard, not what they've experienced for themselves. That's not always the case of course, and like I said, I've tried PvP in other games and I enjoy those for those games. At its worst now, and its best then, I still enjoy XIV PvP.