I get that, I really do, my opposition has nothing to do with impeed's someone enjoyment of the game because they make more money in RL. That is fine and something that should be considered when making extra stuff in the mog station and what prices to set for all the extra stuff.
I am opposed to it because the game's econ can't support it, it is the worst econ system I seen. First off the rich simply horde gil because there is nothing to do with it, they have the power to buy 10+ large if they could, some people have cap gil (999~ basically a billion gil on more then one retainer.) Now picture gil like this more in circulation for many to hold what happens? The housing shortage gets even worse, more people try flip them dispite being against the tos, and it may even provoke those that do not know better to monopolize the MB. If you can do it on a huge server such as mine what about the smaller ones? If the game econ actually was active I would think different but in the current state it just cause problems.
More gil spread around = more server load problems when housing is released then what we had on 3.4. I tried logging on the second servers went up but got disconnected twice because the congestion was unreal. The only way to solve it is to have more ways to spend gil, and raise the housing prices. IF SE can't meet the demands of housing, they need to increase the price and have the price balance things. People complained about 70 ish mil for larges when housing was first released because people had 1/100th of the gil they have today. They make the prices smaller when there is an af ton more gil being horded and that doesn't make sense to me.
You are going to have people spending 400-1000+ dollars on housing if they released this, that is how much people have gil wise, and how big the shortage is. Once you move that in RL, the prices are going to get insane till it finds a balance. Trust me I seen those 1k + KC stories, do not think the same will happen with housing should such a system get released.
Despite the huge benefit I would get if this should be in place, I am still apposed to it because of all the problems it would cause. Personally I would benefit, np but the general health of the econ be exponentially worse then what we see now.