Why cant we compare reprisal to dismantle? they are the same and ANY tank can take it, if dismantle was unique to MCH it would be different but the fact that any tank can get the same skill with no real lose is a big deal.The Fact that it is a JOB skill and not an role action means it should be better, and yet it is on the same level. I didn't say it invalidates dismantle but it lowers the value of MCH. "catching up" is the key here as I said couple posts ago Bard can still out dps a mch with it rng its hard to balance around this, and if we really want to get into it mch is much more punishing if you mess up or don't have a nice ping.