Monk's not wanting to play without heavy physical groups?

[SpeckledBurd]

Yeah I've had this issue. The other night most of my group was helping someone out with O3S and the other Melee was absent, even with only one fewer physical the number of Chakras you get is pretty noticeably impacted.

It's even worse in 4-mans, the matchmaking prioritizes putting a melee with a ranged so you've effectively got a 2/5 chance of having a physical 2nd DPS, and when the only other Physical is the tank Brotherhood is only good for 2-3 Chakras. It's bad enough that I've switched to Samurai for EX roulette so my damage isn't so impacted by the whims of the DF.

Honestly they don't even need to change the buff from being physical damage only, but at leastl let let chakras proc from spells.

[KingFrost]

I don't understand why spells don't give chakra. TFC has a cooldown regardless, so the number of TFC in n RoF would still be the same in either best case scenario. It would just make the skill much less likely to be randomly useless/extremely underwhelming.

[TheMax1087]

Should probably be pointed out that while rdm enchanted melee isn't affected by brotherhood because they do magic damage, it still gives chakra because they're weaponskills, so at least 1 of the 3 casters are ok.

[Rawrz]

Should probably be pointed out that while rdm enchanted melee isn't affected by brotherhood because they do magic damage, it still gives chakra because they're weaponskills, so at least 1 of the 3 casters are ok.

Pointed out on page 1 already