Craft leveling

[Tenshi]

Using skills adds to the time consuming process. If the effect of abilities was more pronounced I think I would enjoy it more.

The abilities currently vary quite a bit in usefulness, but there are a few that are really awesome and make a huge difference in success rates.

I used to try harder items and use abilities for more xp but it was just so random. I could use every ability I could and still fail then next succeed with most of the durability remaining.

There is an element of randomness, yeah--it would be completely predictable otherwise. The key for me has been to find a "sweet spot" that gives 500+ exp per item and is challenging, but not impossible. Then I have to pay very close attention in order to succeed, and I find that rewarding. Those sweet spots depend upon level difference, the gear you have, and whether you've purchased a guild bonus (among other things).