Page 7 of 14 FirstFirst ... 5 6 7 8 9 ... LastLast
Results 61 to 70 of 166

Hybrid View

  1. #1
    Player
    Falar's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2016
    Location
    Ul'Dah
    Posts
    502
    Character
    Kane Blackstone
    World
    Ultros
    Main Class
    Dark Knight Lv 90
    Quote Originally Posted by Harz View Post
    Another issue here is that this makes pentamelded crafted BiS for tanks because HQ crafted has 40 strength and 5 slots to meld more strength and then a bunch of crit/direct hit.

    Why are tanks the only role that has to shell out an inordinate amount of gil and materia just to be optimal?
    Good point.

    Usually pentamelds fall short since they have so much less mainstat.

    Here, it is likely to be the same or no change so the way to go will be just like you said--STR in the primary slot, then all DH.

    Can't wait to see the first tier of crafted gear, should be....i320 if the formula follows. At this rate I wish they would allow advanced melding of primary stats again.

    If they did that, I would STFU immediately about the low # of strength they put on our gear.


    Quote Originally Posted by Klongol View Post
    Sigh. 317 RDM and 314 DRK. I'm a Tank. Is my statement any more valid?

    To your point, I'm sure no tank would balk at MORE str... But starting low and going high it's better than starting high and going low... Both from a development standpoint and a pr standpoint. Nerfing str later would likely cause some here to have a brain aneurysm.


    Starting at 70-80% would have been high, sure.

    I don't understand why they didn't do 50%. But hey, maybe you're right, we could end up there eventually. But I have my doubts.
    (0)

  2. #2
    Player
    Rbstr's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2013
    Posts
    512
    Character
    Robin Ster
    World
    Sargatanas
    Main Class
    Marauder Lv 70
    It's very clear SE wants tanks to do less damage. That's fine as a concept, given you don't want tanks to simply be DPS with a bunch more survivability.
    The things I really don't get are:
    Why do they want tanks' attack power and enmity to unsustainable without future meddling?
    Why do they want accessory upgrades for tanks to be worth so little?

    On the latter question - we've never needed to have the HP levels that ilevel-current accessories have given us in the past and nothing appears to have changed there. Thus accessory upgrades are basically wasted until everything else has been done already. They're essentially useless savage drops they won't substantially help you clear the later fights. 2 str for 20 ilevels does not change that.

    On the former question: They already had a semi-permanent solution with half-vit/str scaling and they threw it away! SO it really appears they want tanks to not scale...
    It's plain to see that a some arbitrary future ilvl tanks won't hold hate because they grow slower than DPS. They will have to change enmity modifiers or make tank accs have a big jump in added str or something in the future. Be it 5.0 or whatever.

    Even if they don't want to go back to the old way because of the new res sickness there're ton' of ways they could fix it permanently and still reduce tank damage vs. dps. Give tanks full strength on accessories but make attack power .9*str (or .8 or .7 or whatever) instead of 1-to-1. Or they could make tank accessories give exactly .5 (or .4 or .6 or whatever) the DPS accessories. All it has to do is increase at the same rate as the DPS somehow. Problem solved in perpetuity - If tanks can hold hate now they will be able to in the future as well.

    That would also solve the problem that it really sucks from the player perspective to continually get worse, and fall father and farther behind, relative to other players even as you increase in ilvl yourself.
    (1)
    Last edited by Rbstr; 07-19-2017 at 01:03 AM.

  3. #3
    Player
    Tihm81's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2013
    Posts
    8
    Character
    Tazz Burrfoot
    World
    Coeurl
    Main Class
    Paladin Lv 60
    It seems to me that SE had realized that tank/dps balance is off from what they want. They made major adjustments with the release of SB. Now they're trying to get the player base used to their (SE's) idea of balance. At the same time, they aren't able to fully realize the results without letting the players play. I think they either did a decent job taking player feedback (i.e. stance swapping) or their numbers corroborated what player feedback was saying (i.e STR acc). I think once the balance is to their liking, tank and DPS STR will rise at the same level and tank enmity will be a constant. Personally, I think it does no good for a tank to compare their DPS to a damage dealer. I think a tank should be able to hold enmity while pushing out their max DPS, but a damage dealer should always do more DPS.
    (0)

  4. #4
    Player
    KingFrost's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2015
    Posts
    101
    Character
    Arc Papillon
    World
    Jenova
    Main Class
    Pugilist Lv 70
    I wonder, how seemingly impossibly far off into the future would we have to go for this not to be solved by an extra Butcher's Block or two. No being facetious, but seriously asking, given how much of a joke enmity is in this game, how great would the deficit have to be to where you'd have to care more about enmity than... past an Unchained opener.
    (1)

  5. #5
    Player
    StouterTaru's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2013
    Posts
    3,464
    Character
    Stouter Taru
    World
    Exodus
    Main Class
    Thaumaturge Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by KingFrost View Post
    I wonder, how seemingly impossibly far off into the future would we have to go for this not to be solved by an extra Butcher's Block or two. No being facetious, but seriously asking, given how much of a joke enmity is in this game, how great would the deficit have to be to where you'd have to care more about enmity than... past an Unchained opener.
    They gave casters a skill to dump half their hate with 4.0, melee have diversion and other skills, OT has shirk, and if you're losing hate to a brd/mch...
    (0)

  6. #6
    Player
    BlackironTarkus's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2015
    Location
    Ul'Dah
    Posts
    104
    Character
    Jin Karasu
    World
    Balmung
    Main Class
    Dark Knight Lv 90
    Quote Originally Posted by Ariyn View Post
    The only thing you are griping about is that you can't do leet deeps while being a tank. Sorry but if you want to see big numbers roll dps.
    Never has this been my stance. If you look at the thread instead of just trying to relegate me to another "hurrr dps tank like" half the of so fondly likes to do, you'd see I don't want us to do as much as a dps, I'm advocating to keep us at a permanent fixed percentage behind dps damage so that they won't have to keep going in and screwing with tank damage or patching in enmity buffs like they have been since the start of heavensward.

    The current state of things means that dps will get better at damage faster than tanks do, they have a better rate of return on their gear upgrades. It's unsustainable.

    Try actually reading my responses and position on the topic or just fully read the original post before you go shooting off about "oh you're just whining about not being able to big dick dps while you tank".
    (2)

  7. #7
    Player
    Ariyn's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2013
    Posts
    305
    Character
    Enitzu Zen'yr
    World
    Goblin
    Main Class
    Paladin Lv 70
    Quote Originally Posted by BlackironTarkus View Post
    Never has this been my stance. If you look at the thread instead of just trying to relegate me to another "hurrr dps tank like" half the of so fondly likes to do, you'd see I don't want us to do as much as a dps, I'm advocating to keep us at a permanent fixed percentage behind dps damage so that they won't have to keep going in and screwing with tank damage or patching in enmity buffs like they have been since the start of heavensward.

    The current state of things means that dps will get better at damage faster than tanks do, they have a better rate of return on their gear upgrades. It's unsustainable.

    Try actually reading my responses and position on the topic or just fully read the original post before you go shooting off about "oh you're just whining about not being able to big dick dps while you tank".
    Oh I've read your posts. And there all the same, pointless waste of time. You keep harping over this being about being able to stay ahead of the DPS in terms of emnity but the fact is emnity is a joke. Is it not now nor ever will be a thing we will worry about. The fact that I can stay in DPS stance and never do a single emnity combo and still never lose threat is more than enough to show that.

    But sure, let's keep trying the "I'm not looking for DPS" tactic. There's bound to be a bunch of fools here to follow your lead. If you have a single issue with threat then the problem isn't with the class it's with you as a player. Tank damage means NOTHING unless they put in another fight where tank and healer damage matters, which they have already stated was a mistake and won't be doing again. DPS can get better than us by more than 10 times the damage and we still would not face many issues holding threat. The simple fact is currently emnity is a flat out joke. Past the first 10 seconds of a pull there is no dps that will pull off a tank unless hes dead.
    (1)

  8. #8
    Player
    Klongol's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2016
    Posts
    49
    Character
    Klongol Eartheye
    World
    Cactuar
    Main Class
    Red Mage Lv 70
    people, as usual, are jumping to conclusions. They see only 2 str difference between 20 item levels and immediately extrapolate that to mean that the sky is falling... again.

    The order of events are as follows:

    - Tanks focus on DPS for an entire expansion, mainly due to poor savage raid design / overtuning
    - 4.0 releases and SE makes it so STR accessories are not usable by tanks 61 and up.
    - Tanks get mad at this and don't like their deeps, also claim they can't hold threat without STR accessories. They continue to wear the i270 STR accessories.
    - SE patches threat - increasing it a lot
    - Tanks STILL use i270 weapons, state that it's because of some alleged meta they have to follow. Many healers lament.
    - Tanks suggest, among other things, adding STR to Fending accessories, even admit that lower STR than DPS classes is fine.
    - SE patches and adds STR to fending accessories.
    - Tanks once again complain that they think it's not enough.

    Come ON people. We have no idea how they will scale STR on future accessories. We only know what we can see. Stop complaining for a goddamn minute. Hell, YOU GOT WHAT YOU WANTED!

    As others have posted, it looks like it will take hundreds of item levels for the differences people are assuming will occur are felt... if ever. People are not considering how secondary stats play into it. People are STILL saying they will use STR accessories...

    I just don't understand this Tank forum sometimes =/
    (6)

  9. #9
    Player
    Falar's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2016
    Location
    Ul'Dah
    Posts
    502
    Character
    Kane Blackstone
    World
    Ultros
    Main Class
    Dark Knight Lv 90
    Quote Originally Posted by Klongol View Post
    people, as usual, are jumping to conclusions. They see only 2 str difference between 20 item levels and immediately extrapolate that to mean that the sky is falling... again.

    The order of events are as follows:

    - Tanks focus on DPS for an entire expansion, mainly due to poor savage raid design / overtuning
    - 4.0 releases and SE makes it so STR accessories are not usable by tanks 61 and up.
    - Tanks get mad at this and don't like their deeps, also claim they can't hold threat without STR accessories. They continue to wear the i270 STR accessories.
    - SE patches threat - increasing it a lot
    - Tanks STILL use i270 weapons, state that it's because of some alleged meta they have to follow. Many healers lament.
    - Tanks suggest, among other things, adding STR to Fending accessories, even admit that lower STR than DPS classes is fine.
    - SE patches and adds STR to fending accessories.
    - Tanks once again complain that they think it's not enough.

    Come ON people. We have no idea how they will scale STR on future accessories. We only know what we can see. Stop complaining for a goddamn minute. Hell, YOU GOT WHAT YOU WANTED!

    As others have posted, it looks like it will take hundreds of item levels for the differences people are assuming will occur are felt... if ever. People are not considering how secondary stats play into it. People are STILL saying they will use STR accessories...

    I just don't understand this Tank forum sometimes =/
    Well......maybe that is because you are a DPS.

    Lowering our attack power to be FAR lower than it used to be relative to the DPS roles did massively effect enmity.

    In 3.xx, assuming I wasn't outgeared, I never had problems holding enmity after an initial aggro combo. When I hit 70 in SB it was unreal how Samurai and Red mage could climb the charts on me. No one wants to use diversion (because "lul, don't be so bad tank"). Putting i270 slaying accessories changed all that, and felt damn good doing it.

    STR on fending accessories needed to happen. I would have preferred this to the lame ass 3.xx "fix" but this is too low. They need to have 50% of the VIT to start out and then go up from there if necessary. This was just too low of a point to start from. It is like they don't even try.
    (0)

  10. #10
    Player
    Reynhart's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2011
    Location
    Ul'Dah
    Posts
    4,605
    Character
    Reynhart Kristensen
    World
    Ragnarok
    Main Class
    Dark Knight Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Klongol View Post
    - Tanks get mad at this and don't like their deeps, also claim they can't hold threat without STR accessories.
    Which is probaly because most of them refuse to use their tank stance and/or their enmity combo without having the skill to pull that properly.
    (2)

Page 7 of 14 FirstFirst ... 5 6 7 8 9 ... LastLast