Oh well i see opinions differ here. While Tanking as a Paladin it feels like im getting a lot less damage (no not only because of shield oath) and Healers can do way more dps. As a Warrior. I eat heavy hits even with Defensive CD's and since Tanks have shared gear, this doesnt seem to be the Problem.....

Also Tenacy is useless until we can stack it up into the thousands and thousands since how extremely low it scales. There is a Reason that most Tanks still go Crit or direct hit. There is also a Reason that People lock PLD and DRK in the Pf Tool so you cant join as a WAR. But i guess everyone knows better than everyone. (<--- Yes this is intended)