Please nerf RDM!

[Galvuu]

snip

You can kill the new primals in 6 minutes and the enrage timer is over 11 minutes...
If a group is "struggling" to kill these primals, they simply lack the fundamental knowledge to perform at a basic level... these "nerfs" and "buffs" are inconsequential to them because they can't play the job in the first place...

[Eydis]

snip

Why don't you tell that to the mass amount of people that are struggling to get their wins. Not me, I know the fights, I have countless wins and several ilvl315+ jobs. I frequently go into party finder and help people get their clears.

Nerfing a high end dps only makes the game harder for others.

Can't tell you how many players I have seen screwed over on their 40+ minute duty finder queue because someone jackass tank or healer got mad that some new guy didn't know mechanics and bailed on the first wipe.

Tell that 6 minute clear to the people that are struggling because nobody will stick around to help them, tell it to the people that can't clear the lvl 70 susano dummy in time and need to be carried by a rdm or sam.

[Galvuu]

Why don't you tell that to the mass amount of people that are struggling to get their wins.

Sure I do.
I join clear/practice parties all the time, and try my best to tell them what they're doing wrong- both in the fight and their job.
And I'm telling you this now because you brought it up as a justification against nerfs in general.
How is "there are people who don't know how to play very well, so we must leave a job that's (potentially) too strong the way it is" an argument?
I'm not even in the "nerf RDM" camp, but that argument is very silly.
"We shouldn't nerf X job because someone out there can't clear an EX primal"...?

Edit: Not to mention that literally 95% of the enrages I see are people dying constantly to mechanics (lowers dps) or completely disregarding their rotations. If MCH can clear these primals with 4 minutes of leeway in respect to the enrage, there's no way any slight RDM nerfs will make them unable to clear the new primals due to "enrages". This isn't Thordan (and even if it was, that argument would hold no weight whatsoever).